Home (Post) Mobile Authors Say Anything Register Login

Monday, November 20, 2006

A Shutdown at the Favor Factory

Washington Post..

While House Republicans reacted to stinging rejection from America’s voters by refusing to change leadership, their Senate counterparts have tried to use their closing weeks in power to enact a last burst of pork-barrel spending. But that effort was stalled last week by independent-minded Republican senators, spearheaded by two abrasive freshmen and one longtime hair shirt. Before Congress recessed Friday for Thanksgiving, the GOP leadership appeared to capitulate.

The freshmen, Tom Coburn and Jim DeMint, campaigning in 2004 in Oklahoma and South Carolina, promised not to fall in line with GOP leaders. Fulfilling that pledge allied them with the long-termer John McCain. They have been backed by Jeff Sessions of Alabama and another freshman, John E. Sununu of New Hampshire. In the lame-duck session’s first week, they played Horatio at the Bridge by combining to block a pork-filled omnibus spending bill.

The bipartisan dismay the dissenters have caused cannot be exaggerated. Hard-working staffers are beside themselves that their lame-duck feast of pork is being thwarted. K Street lobbyists are frustrated that they are being deprived of a vehicle for their special-interest amendments.

Senate Appropriations Committee Chairman Thad Cochran wanted President Bush, in Asia on a trade mission, to phone DeMint and ask him to stop blocking the agriculture appropriations bill. It did not happen, and the Republican leaders mournfully agreed to the cost-cutting resolution. An irate House Appropriations Chairman Jerry Lewis, who has taken pride in passing his committee’s bills on schedule and filled with earmarks, called the outcome an “absolute disaster and catastrophe.”

Among senators wailing that their pet projects are being derailed, none has been louder than Democrat Kent Conrad, who will be Budget Committee chairman in the new Congress. A self-described fiscal conservative (because he wants tax increases), Conrad submitted 41 proposals busting the Bush budget in 2005 alone. He was so distraught last week that the agriculture money bill blocked by DeMint contained $4.9 billion in additional emergency relief that he threatened to stop any money bills from passing in the lame-duck session. He did not follow through with this program of actually closing the government

.
...

Comments

Allow me to play the skeptic here....this opposition to the appropriations bill may be justified.  Then again, it may be little more than petty politics.

Just because somebody calls something pork doesn’t make it so. Take Anon’s favorite pork buster, Rep. Flake of AZ who apparently was unable in two years to actually point to an earmark that actually didn’t make sense.

The way I see it, there are two reasons why one might argue against earmarks.  One is that they might be fiscally irresponsible.  In that case, the onus is on you to demonstrate that they are wasteful.  (If you chose to be non-confrontatational, fine, then the onus is on the bill writer, but you’ve started with a political attack, so it shifts to you).

The second is that earmarks may lead to quid pro quos and might contribute to government corruption.

If you can’t demonstrate that overall they are even wasteful, then an improving of the process to increase the transparency might be in order, while retaining the earmark appropriations mechanism.  As I have pointed out in the past, earmark spending may be regarded as the ultimate expression of Republicanism, namely a distributed rather than a centralized decision making process on how to spend the tax dollars generated in Washington.  (AGAIN, that doesn’t argue that more oversight wouldn’t be helpful.)

So forgive me if my nipples don’t get hard because a couple of congressmen decided to show everybody “what for”.  If they had fixed the problem with runaway entitlement spending...now that’d be something to get excited about.  This...is just posturing.

Carrick on November 20, 2006 at 08:40 pm
Page 1 of 1        

Post a Comment


Before commenting, please recite:

Grant me the serenity to ignore the trolls,
the courage to debate with honest opponents,
and the wisdom to know the difference.

Name   
Email   
URL   
Human?
  
 

Upload Image    

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Note: Notifications will only be sent to confirmed email addresses. Confirm your email address here.

    

By submitting your comment you agree to our terms of service.