Who is generous and who isn’t
There was a thread here last week about how much more generous conservatives are than liberals, the assertion based on a book (Who Really Cares) written a few years ago. I and other liberals maintain that the discrepancy isn’t that large between the groups of religious and on the secular side, the liberals are much more generous than conservatives. An analysis of the book’s findings indicate the same.
Religious giving also factors in as conservatives make up a larger percentage of the religious and give regularly to their churches, something that may not count as much, being largely self-serving.
As it turns out, a new book is causing a lot of hand-wringing over the “stingy” nature of American Christians, making the assumption of religious giving among conservatives suspect by seeming to contradict the conclusions of the earlier book, Who Really Cares.
The point here may be that you can’t make assumptions about who gives and why someone gives to charity despite propaganda published to make the right look better.
From a review of the more recent book on a Christian website:
(more...)
