SayAnything Blog
UN Pressures Google Into Banning Critic
Comments (6) | Full Version | Back
Rob - 08:02am on 02/20/2008

The bureaucrats at the United Nations aren’t going to brook any dissent from scrappy internet commentators, and Google is going to help them out with it.

...beginning Feb. 13, Google News users could no longer find new stories from the Inner City Press.

“I think they said, ‘If we can’t get this guy out of the U.N., let’s disappear him from the Internet,’” Lee said.

It began with an innocuous-sounding yet chilling form letter from Google to Lee, e-mailed on Feb. 8:

“We periodically review news sources, particularly following user complaints, to ensure Google News offers a high quality experience for our users,” it said. “When we reviewed your site we’ve found that we can no longer include it in Google News.”

As soon as he read it, Lee immediately suspected one thing: That someone at the UNDP had pressured Google into “de-listing” him from Google News — essentially preventing Inner City Press from being classified on Google News as a legitimate news source and from having its stories pop up when someone conducts a Google News search.

Over the last couple of years, Lee has proved to be a constant — and controversial — thorn in the U.N.’s side.

Though his writing is clunky, his methods unorthodox (and often highly annoying) and his news judgment sometimes more than a little off the mark, Lee has hit his share of bull’s-eyes and became an outlet for whistleblowers inside the U.N.

In 2006, for example, he drew attention to human-rights abuses by the Ugandan People’s Defense Force during a U.N. disarmament program, including incidents in which four people were killed and over 100 homes destroyed.

In November 2007, during a press conference in which Google announced its partnership with the UNDP to achieve anti-poverty goals, Lee earned a less-than-friendly response when he asked why the Internet company hadn’t signed a global human-rights and anti-censorship compact —elements in the U.N.’s Millennium Development Goals.

I guess now we know why.

Beyond the free speech issues, which are important believe you me, there’s the question of why anyone at Google thought this was a good idea.  Before this happened, how many people had actually heard of this guy?  Not many, I’d guess.  I certainly hadn’t.  But now?  He’s got a lot more attention all of a sudden, and Google’s reputation for being a fair index of online information is a good deal more tarnished.

All Google, and the United Nations which pressured the company into this, has done is act exactly like Mr. Lee has been telling people they act.


Read Comments (6)