Video: Neal Cavuto And Bill O’Reilly Almost Get Into A Fight Over Gas Prices

I watched this live on television last night and was hoping it’d show up on YouTube.


Logical reasoning based on empirical observations versus emotional arguments based on frustration and anger.
Guess which one wins?

Tags:


«
»
  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    I had a thought. I wonder if Bill thinks state owned oil companies in Europe are gouging their customers as well?

  • Dt Thomas A Brosky II

    I recently saw a piece on health care with Neil interviewing Senator John Shadegg from Arizona, the senator referred to Podiatry as an ESOTERIC field and related podiatry to aroma therapy. I am appalled at his remarks and would like him to clarify his remarks. I don’t not defend my profession but he needs to clarify his remarks since I pay his salary. Dr. T.A. Brosky II

  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    I quit watch O’reilly a long time ago.

    For the most part, he’s a waste of time.

  • atease

    Folks can say what they want to about FNC, but they are real. I was laughing when this was on last night. Neil called him on the carpet for being wrong. You will never see Obie or Matty being taken to the woodshed on their stations.

    atease

  • Bat One

    I second both comments above… heartily. The idea that Bill O’Reilly is some kind of rightwing conservative is laughable.

    I don’t much care for his style. His self-promotion is smarmy and shameless, with none of the self-deprecating savoire fair and humor that comes so naturally to Rush.

    But O’Reilly is most certainly “fair and balanced.” His interview of McCain was as hard-hitting and incisive as his Obama interview.

  • patriot

    Good, we need to have MORE discussions on gas prices, at least someone is having them.

    On whether or not Bill O’Reilly is ‘conservative’ or ‘republican’. The Saturday before the convention the City of Mpls had a ‘media’ party outdoors, on the River, by the Guthrie and the Mill City Museum. Megyn Kelly, from FOX, was at that party, among a few others. She was very, very nice; as we talked with her someone asked “So whose better, Hannity or O’Reilly?” She laughed, “Both are great, but they’re two totally different approaches, Sean is just what he seems a pure Conservative Republican; Bill is more libertarian minded.” That was of course the nicely diplomatic answer by Kelly, but she was pretty gracious about answering it.

  • http://www.valleydeals.com/cgi-bin/board2/YaBB.pl Kevin

    O’Reily is just spouting the environut nonsense he was indoctrinated with when he was a high school teacher.
    I remember the same gas price conspiracy theory back in the seventies.

  • http://insanereindeer.blogspot.com/ Kenny

    What kind of a business person doesn’t try to maximize profit by keeping costs as low as possible and keeping prices as high as the market will allow?

    The kind of businessman who is constantly investigated and being threatened with profit confiscation. I agree with Neil, they could charge more than they do, but they don’t because of blowhards like O’really? who cluelessly spout off about oil.

  • http://www.bikebubba.blogspot.com/ Bike Bubba

    The one big mistake that Cavuto made, IMO, is in denying that oil companies are out to maximize profit. If they’re not doing that for the long term, they owe investors their resignations.

    But O’Reilly…yeesh…

  • http://www.valleydeals.com/cgi-bin/board2/YaBB.pl Kevin

    O’Reily is just spouting the environut nonsense he was indoctrinated with when he was a high school teacher.
    I remember the same gas price conspiracy theory back in the seventies.

  • LJ

    Bill was closer to being right than Neal was. There are many factors such as refining, transprortation, etc that determine the price of a gallon of gas. Just because the cost of 1 componant triples does not automatically triple every cost involved in making a gallon of gas. Neal should do some homework before spouting off.

  • Paulie B

    BO ran in terror of Cavuto’s gas logic… and he changed the subject. O’Reilly’s show is on when I drive home from work most of the time, and I can’t stand when he talks about gas prices… it’s all emotion with no substance. Cavuto kicked his @$$ here; BO had to go and change the subject, but Cavuto brought it back on track with the main point… the gov’t ain’t the answer.

  • http://insanereindeer.blogspot.com/ Kenny

    Bill was closer to being right than Neal was. There are many factors such as refining, transprortation, etc that determine the price of a gallon of gas. Just because the cost of 1 componant triples does not automatically triple every cost involved in making a gallon of gas. Neal should do some homework before spouting off.

    The same is also true in reverse though. Just because crude oil drops 33% doesn’t mean that the cost of making gas drops 33%. Neal wasn’t wrong at all. O’Reilly didn’t care that the cost didn’t inflate at the same rate as the crude oil, but he cared that it didn’t deflate at the same percentage. O’Reilly was being dishonest, and Cavuto caught him in it. Next time you should get basic debating tactics and listening comprehension before spouting off.

    Why you would want to pay more for gas is beyond me. McCain also threatened to guilt corporations into being reasonable with Americans.

    First, he threatened to punish corporations, not guilt them. That’s a huge difference. Second, fair is subjective. Let’s say a gas company started operating like a clothing store, with 50% markup and 35-40% profit margin, instead of the piddly 3-4% they charge now. 3.50 gas would become 5.20 gas. Then they markup taxes and fees they have to pay at about 10%. 5 dollars goes to 6. No one complains when they pay 15 dollars for a shirt that cost a buck to make, but when they pay 350 for a gallon of gas that cost 3.35 to make and produce…THAT is highway robbery!

    No one complains about the near extortionate bottled water return. Who in good conscience can sell a bottle of WATER for 4 bucks? Fountain soda has a profit margin of over 300%. Some places charge for AIR. No one gripes about this…because its not a good stick to beat capitalists with. Oil however….whistles….

  • Hannitized

    No one complains when they pay 15 dollars for a shirt that cost a buck to make, but when they pay 350 for a gallon of gas that cost 3.35 to make and produce…THAT is highway robbery!

    That is true, but at the same time nobody makes decisions on how far they can buy a home from work based on the price of a t-shirt.

    You start drastically changing the value of gas in a short time period and you are going to see shock-waves through the economy that would have devastating and disastrous results.

  • http://www.valleydeals.com/cgi-bin/board2/YaBB.pl Kevin

    Why does realitybasedbob hate school teachers?

  • LJ

    Bill was closer to being right than Neal was. There are many factors such as refining, transprortation, etc that determine the price of a gallon of gas. Just because the cost of 1 componant triples does not automatically triple every cost involved in making a gallon of gas. Neal should do some homework before spouting off.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com/readers/author/realitybasedbob/ realitybasedbob

    Billow Reilly is a great conservative culture warrior.

    Since B1 Bob Dornan got his ass handed to him a few years ago, nutters are lucky to have a true conservative like Billow to tell them what to think.

    Except for that messy falafel phone sex thing that cost him 10 mil., the Malmédy mix up, getting faced by Stuart Smally, his lies about Levitt Town, phony football stats and his violent temper, he is a true red conservative.

    Whatja expect, 6’5″ Billow to pick on a little handicapped guy?

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic

    Oh…sorry… never mind…

  • LJ

    Bill was closer to being right than Neal was. There are many factors such as refining, transprortation, etc that determine the price of a gallon of gas. Just because the cost of 1 componant triples does not automatically triple every cost involved in making a gallon of gas. Neal should do some homework before spouting off.

  • Hannitized

    … they could charge more than they do, but they don’t because of blowhards like O’really? who cluelessly spout off about oil.

    If that is the case, than good for O’Reilly, he really IS looking out for us.

    Why you would want to pay more for gas is beyond me. McCain also threatened to guilt corporations into being reasonable with Americans.

    I guess you better vote for the Democrat. ;)

  • robert108

    Billow Reilly is a great conservative culture warrior.

    Goebbels lies again.

  • sayanything-2407

    Bill O’Reilly is a commentator, opinion, that speaks about current events / politics.

    He is not a newscaster, news anchor or reporter.

    I don’t overly like him, and in some ways he and Olbermann are like opposite sides of the coin to a degree. Yes, I said to a degree. In alot of ways Olbermann is just nuts I think, where O’Reilly can be obnoxious in his points – they are his opinion, and not the news.

    It is like putting someone who is a commentator (opinion) and having them debate a real news person who knows exactly what is going on.

    Cavuto knows what he is talking about, where as Bill just reacts to what he hears, reads and gets told.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    The one big mistake that Cavuto made, IMO, is in denying that oil companies are out to maximize profit. If they’re not doing that for the long term, they owe investors their resignations.

    Yeah, I didn’t like that part of Cavuto’s argument either, but O’Reilly asked it as though it were a bad thing.

    What kind of a business person doesn’t try to maximize profit by keeping costs as low as possible and keeping prices as high as the market will allow?

    Everyone wants a better margin. There’s nothing wrong with that.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com/readers/author/sparkiearbuckle sayanything-81

    BO is a special ed case. I loved hearing him talk about Palins daughter and how this stuff just happens sometimes… then talking about Brittney Spears sister, he referred to the parents as ‘pinheads’. By ASSociation, we can infer that he believes the Palin’s are pinheads.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com/readers/author/sparkiearbuckle sayanything-81

    Shame they weren’t armed.

    They were, but their handlers didn’t want to remove their straight jackets. It just appeared as if they were armless.

  • WOOFX

    Shame they weren’t armed.

Create a SAB Readerblog


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Blog Advice and Support
Installs and Upgrades
Theme Modifications
Custom Plugins
Theme Design
Conversions and Relocations
Hacked Site Recovery
Mobile Apps Development