The Power Of Will

Victor Davis Hanson:

Yes, it is a strange war. Jihadists are amused that a few American soldiers, worried over their safety, can refuse orders, call 7,000 miles home in anguish, and expect that their complaints, handed over by Mom to the local TV station, will turn up on national cable news before their own commanders in the field even know what is up. A teenaged terrorist with a RPG, being filmed as he is killed, is every bit as an effective soldier through his globally broadcast death than had he lived on to hit his target Humvee with his rocket in the first place. We don’t ask, “Which school-builder or power-restorer was he trying to obliterate?” but rather “Why did we have to kill him?”
When the Islamists behead a tearful Englishman or American, it is more likely that his surviving dad or sibling back home will be on television all over the Middle East within minutes damning Tony Blair or George Bush, without a word of censure for the Dark-Age head-loppers. After all, we are not Nepalese who storm the local mosque and put the fear of God into Islamists when they butcher our own. We are more likely to be frightened, turn on ourselves, and condemn some American somewhere who cannot stop “this.”

Read the whole thing.
Is it any wonder that America hasn’t won a decisive victory in a war since the proliferation of television and television news?

Tags:


«
»
  • http://Array attobuoy

    You forgot about Grenada.

  • brandy

    To be honest, most wars are not won or lost militarily but politically. In this case we are fighting over the hearts-and-minds of the Iraqis (in the first place) and the whole of the Middle East (in the second place).

    We will lose the war if we allow the terrorists to drive a wedge between us and the Iraqi people. They do this by provoking us to dropping bombs on cities like Faluja or taking other heavy-handed actions which you are suggesting. The terrorists in Iraq have grown from an army of 2 thousand foreigners a year ago to 20 or 30 thousand Iraqis today.

    Now, to change the situation you describe we really need to make sure our troops are well equipped, well supported and motivated. They can’t do this when most of their humvees do not have the proper armour and they get sent on stupid suicide missions. Yes, it is war, so if they refuse to follow orders to go against the enemy then let’s line them against the wall and shoot them (I mean this metaphorically, not literally). But if it turns out that they were right and we are ordering them to do things that do not match the real conditions on the ground, or that we are not giving them proper equipment and support, then we just look stupid!

Create a SAB Readerblog


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Blog Advice and Support
Installs and Upgrades
Theme Modifications
Custom Plugins
Theme Design
Conversions and Relocations
Hacked Site Recovery
Mobile Apps Development