The David Shuster Kerfuffle Illustrates The Media’s Double Standards

Howard Kurtz sums up David Shuster’s fall from grace after saying “Doesn’t it seem as if Chelsea is sort of being pimped out in some weird sort of way?”:

In case there was any doubt, using a prostitution metaphor for the daughter of a presidential candidate is not a good career move.
MSNBC suspended correspondent David Shuster yesterday for an undetermined period for making a disparaging on-air remark about Chelsea Clinton. Meanwhile, officials in her mother’s campaign raised the possibility of punishing the news channel by boycotting future debates.
While filling in as a host Thursday, Shuster was discussing the 27-year-old’s role in Hillary Rodham Clinton’s campaign with two guests when he asked: “Doesn’t it seem as if Chelsea is sort of being pimped out in some weird sort of way?”
Howard Wolfson, the campaign’s communications director, called Shuster’s remark “disgusting,” “beneath contempt” and “the kind of thing that should never be said on a national news network.” Wolfson appeared to suggest that Clinton is reconsidering an agreement this week to participate in an MSNBC debate Feb. 26 in Cleveland, saying: “I at this point can’t envision doing another debate on that network.”
Shuster, who plays a prominent role in MSNBC’s political coverage, told viewers last night that his words were “inappropriate. . . . I apologize to the Clinton family, the Clinton campaign, and all of you who were justifiably offended. . . . I am particularly sorry that my language diminished the regard and respect she has earned from all of us and the respect her parents have earned in how they raised her.”

It’s worth noting that the word “pimp,” as used as a verb, has (unfortunately in my mind) become a part of our national lexicon in a way that doesn’t necessarily have anything specifically to do with prostitution. When we talk of celebrities “pimping” this product or that we aren’t saying those celebrities are literally engaging in pay-for-sex schemes. Even my grandmother gets this.
So it’s curious to see Shuster’s career (the little of it the ignorant hack was able to build for himself) go down the tubes for using this rather innocuous (if grating) term in relation to Chelsea Clinton. Especially in light of some of the treatment President Bush has gotten at the hands of the media. He’s been called a liar. He’s been called stupid. He’s been accused of being a war criminal, a drug addict, an alcoholic, a military deserter and a co-conspirator in the 9/11 attacks.
Over the last eight years the media has collectively dragged President Bush through a rhetorical mud hole over and over again, with each member of the media trying to top the rest with the most vitriolic denunciation of his administration. Yet through all that not one reporter was ever suspended for saying something nasty about the President. In fact, if that had happened, the media establishment would have been beside itself in denouncing the move and its “chilling effect” on the free press.
But you make one comment about Chelsea Clinton and you’ll soon find yourself covering dog shows in Buffalo.
If you ask me this outrage over Shuster’s comment is feigned, at best, not to mention a calculated part of the Clinton campaign strategy. I don’t think Shuster is in cahoots with the Clintons, but the Clintons are undoubtedly behind his public flogging.
How better to distract from Barack Obama’s rising star than to focus the nation’s attention on poor, helpless Chelsea being called a hooker by some reporter?
Update: Will MSNBC now being suspending Keith Olbermann for this comment made back in September of last year?

And in pimping General David Petraeus and in the violation of everything this country has been assiduously and vigilantly against for 220 years, you have tried to blur the gleaming radioactive demarcation between the military and the political, and to portray your party as the one associated with the military, and your opponents as the ones somehow antithetical to it.

If the suggestion of Bill and Hillary “pimping” their daughter is worthy of a suspension, what about the suggestion of our President “pimping” a four-star General?
Aren’t double standards fun?

Tags: , , , ,


«
»
  • http://Array atease

    I believe all are missing the real point. These are mere words which are nothing more than sounds only understandable to a certain percentage of the population. For anyone to be offended is more than rediculous, it is absurd. Sticks and stones hurt. Words cant.

    This is a slippery slope we are all heading down. If must be stopped.

    atease

  • Disappointed


    What happened to the 1st amendment ?? Tho I agree Davids comments were unnecessary and a poor choice, its his right to express his opinion in his own words. And msnbc knuckled under to the clinton team. Shameful at the very least. BRING DAVID SHUSTER BACK asap.

  • atease

    Kenny, don’t play with me please. Apples and oranges and you know it. Accusing someone of rape is 180 degrees away from what was said and is being punished here. It was a mere word that has everyone scrambling for their dictionaries and back checking to see who else may have used the same word.

    Punches are punishable by law. Last I checked, the 1st Admendment to the U.S. Constitution puts this whole conversation to rest. You have the right to speak and show everyone you are an idiot, just what Shuster did.

    atease

  • patriot

    Wow. I’ve never watched Olberman before, I clicked through to the video and actually watched it. He is one angry man.

    I can only assume by his ratings that he’s always like that.

  • http://insanereindeer.blogspot.com/ Kenny

    He’s been called stupid. He’s been accused of being a war criminal, a drug addict, an alcoholic, a military deserter and a co-conspirator in the 9/11 attacks.

    You forgot: racist, coward, draft dodger, murderer, cause of the levees breaking in New Orleans and bridge collapsing last year, thief, religious zealot, and all around monster.

  • Pomerdorgrad

    I find “kerfuffle” offensive. Jack Zaleski uses it.

  • Pomerdorgrad

    Changing, or rather, deteriorating standards allow this kind of selective outrage, when really the outrage was the mainstreaming of “to pimp” in the first place.

    Hip hop culture claims another victim.

  • http://insanereindeer.blogspot.com/ Kenny

    Sticks and stones hurt. Words cant.

    This is a slippery slope we are all heading down. If must be stopped.

    Words carry meanings. And can indeed cause damage. While “rape” (rAp) is only four letters which form a single unbroken sound, an accusation of this variety can put a man in jail or ruin his reputation, even if it is proven false.

    In this vein, punches are only movements that end in a collision and can only be felt by a few people who are in the path of that movement.

    Slippery slope I tell you.

  • eric

    Shuster obviously should be fired. Don’t you remember all the media firings that took place after the derogatory reporting on Bush’s daughters and Cheney’s daughter ? ? ? Their names just seem to slip my mind at the moment…….

Create a SAB Readerblog


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Blog Advice and Support
Installs and Upgrades
Theme Modifications
Custom Plugins
Theme Design
Conversions and Relocations
Hacked Site Recovery
Mobile Apps Development