Home Mobile Archives Reader Blogs Register Login

Thursday, March 31, 2005

Racist Cartoon?

Hmm...

DULUTH, Minn. - The publisher of the Duluth News Tribune issued an apology to readers today after some said they were offended by an editorial cartoon about the Red Lake shootings.

Nine people were killed in the attack on the northwest Minnesota Indian reservation before the gunman, 16-year-old Jeff Weise, killed himself. In the wake of the shooting, people who knew Weise said he talked often of guns and shooting people, and a long trail of Internet postings showed him communicating with others in cyberspace about depression, suicide and violence.

In the cartoon, drawn by Signe Wilkinson of the Philadelphia Daily News, a man with a headband and ponytail holds an 'Indian Tracking Guide' as he walks along a path littered with guns, skulls, swastikas and a picture of Hitler. The man says: 'I'm not recognizing these signs.'

After the cartoon ran in Wednesday's News Tribune, Publisher Marti Buscaglia posted a note to readers:

'Some of our readers have indicated they were offended by the racially derogatory nature of Wednesday's political cartoon commenting on the Red Lake incident. Frankly, I agree with those viewpoints and want to extend my apologies to those who were offended during a sensitive time in our region.'

About 75 people protested outside the newspaper at noon today. Two of the paper's editors - Editorial Page Editor Robin Washington and Executive Editor Rob Karwath - met with some of the protesters to talk and answer questions. They repeated Buscaglia's printed apology, Washington said.


Here's the cartoon:

Racist Cartoon?


I don't find it all that offensive. Rather insightful, really. But then, I'm not an Indian so maybe I'm missing something here.

What do you think?

Comments

Rob
Rob
17185 comments
Send a private message

I’d like to have tracking skills.  To go along with my nunchuck skills and my hacking skills…


The war against illegal plunder has been fought since the beginning of the world. But how is… legal plunder to be identified? Quite simply. See if the law takes from some persons what belongs to them, and gives it to other persons to whom it does not belong. See if the law benefits one citizen at the expense of another by doing what the citizen himself cannot do without committing a crime. Then abolish this law without delay … If such a law is not abolished immediately it will spread, multiply and develop into a system.

Frédéric Bastiat, The Law

Rob’s recently listened-to songs:

robport.gif border=0

Rob on March 31, 2005 at 07:03 pm
Avatar for Chad Evans

On another note of something being called racist involving indians, the University of Illinois mascot has been banned from the Final Four.  The mascot is an indian chief.  I have never understood why indians as mascots are racist.

Chad Evans on March 31, 2005 at 07:03 pm
Avatar for Mark J

Chad, yeah, I get the intent of the cartoon… (and honestly don’t know enough about the case to comment on the validity of its point).  What I don’t get is what about it is racist or offensive to American Indians.

Mark J on March 31, 2005 at 07:03 pm
Avatar for Chad Evans

Heh.  Good.  As you’ve seen in the case of just about anything that shows one person’s race or religious affinity other than a white Christian, it can be turned into being racist.  Sadly, everything from a cartoon showing the Green Giant being racist against tall, green people to a cartoon of a candy bar being discriminatory against diabetics is considered racist.

Chad Evans on March 31, 2005 at 07:03 pm
Rob
Rob
17185 comments
Send a private message

The point being made in the cartoon was that the school had plenty of indication that something was wrong with this student.  He’d been in trouble before.

Also, I heard on the radio that a poll done in the school before this incident showed that 25% of the boys in the school and 45% of the girls (or some numbers along those lines) had thought of killing themselves.  Now I’m not one to put a lot of faith into these polls of students (I think a lot of the kids fool with them or just fill in answers to get them done) but clearly those numbers, which are way out of line with other schools, indicate that something was/is going on there.

But then, there are major problems on most of this country’s Indian reservations.


The war against illegal plunder has been fought since the beginning of the world. But how is… legal plunder to be identified? Quite simply. See if the law takes from some persons what belongs to them, and gives it to other persons to whom it does not belong. See if the law benefits one citizen at the expense of another by doing what the citizen himself cannot do without committing a crime. Then abolish this law without delay … If such a law is not abolished immediately it will spread, multiply and develop into a system.

Frédéric Bastiat, The Law

Rob’s recently listened-to songs:

robport.gif border=0

Rob on March 31, 2005 at 07:03 pm
Avatar for Mark J

I don’t get it… do they think it implies that all American Indians are Nazis?  Is it bad to make reference to the American Indian’s traditional tracking skills?

Mark J on March 31, 2005 at 07:04 pm
Avatar for Chad Evans

I don’t see it as racist either, but then again I do not view many things as being racist. 

Mark, I believe the point was to show that all the signs were there and being ignored, something in which I do not believe was the case.

Chad Evans on March 31, 2005 at 07:04 pm
Avatar for Mark J

Heh… using a brave Indian leader as a mascot is racist, but Notre Dame portraying the Irish as pugnacious diminutive leprechauns is just fine.

Man, get over yourself.

Mark J on March 31, 2005 at 08:03 pm
Avatar for Chad Evans

What about the New England Patriots?  Back during the Revolutionary War, there were not exactly too many non-white people who fought.

Chad Evans on March 31, 2005 at 08:03 pm
Avatar for LoadTheMule

If you don’t see the macabre humor (and insightfulness) of the cartoon, you’re spending way too much time dumbing-down the definition of ‘offensive’.

Regards…

LoadTheMule on April 1, 2005 at 04:04 am
Avatar for Cartoon People With Guns

[...] Other Cartoon People With Guns Sites 256 257 258 259 260 Say Anything “ Racist Cartoon? - March 31, 2005 @ 8:58 pm ?????? Filed under Default. Hmm… knew Weise said he talked often of guns and shooting people, and a long trail of Internet postings ... racist against tall, green people to a cartoon of a candy bar ...  The Smallest Minority - ... A Mistake a Free People Get to Make Only Once ... From North Central Idaho. The War on Guns. Triggerfinger.org ... to the Brady people, because all guns are bad to ...  Taking more guns out of people’s hands - theage.com.au - Further curbs on handgun ownership are squarely in the public interest. - The Age ... letters. editorial. cartoon. business. technology ... For most Australians, guns remain remote things to which they are ... a strong and consistent stand on guns. In the aftermath of ...  The Smallest Minority - ... about 6,000 unwanted guns in the last 10 ... of the people who turned in guns Saturday for gift ... no problem with people getting rid of unwanted guns, but he ...  Telegraph | News | The guns fall silent in holy city as Shia revolt ‘ends’ - Daily news from the UK, business news, countryside news, UK technology news, obituaries and UK education news - telegraph.co.uk, UK online newspaper. ... Network home Advertising Alex cartoon Arts Books Business Classified Ads ... for the Shias. People threw sweets in the air in ...  :: rogerebert.com :: (xhtml) - search reviews. register. You are not logged in. movie Glossary. Eighth Law of Cartoon Thermodynamics. by Trevor Paquette and Lt. Justin D. Baldwin. Cartoon Law VIII. Any violent rearrangement of feline matter is impermanent. ... the story of what people were willing to do to ...  Issue One: Gun Control in America - Issue One: Gun Control in America. Sunday, March 19, 2000. Unenforceable laws. This letter concerns President Clinton’s call for a new gun bill. ... There is a problem with some people and guns; let us look for a real solution, not another ... by the March 3 Tim Menees cartoon after the shootings in Wilkinsburg ...  Guns, Germs & Steeled “ Watch the Cartoon: Clear Skies? Not! - Commentary from Dr. Stephen C. Nodvin. Jun 17, 2003. The current administration does a great job of marketing. They came up with a new plan called “The Clear Skies Initiative.” The plan actually weakens the 1990 Clean Air Act. ... into becoming part of a shameful marketing campaign that is dishonest to the American people. ...  Bowling for Truth - A Brief History of America - ... A Brief History of America. Cartoon claims scared racist white people responsible for histories gun crimes ... Although no such “black people can’t own guns” law existed, it’s true ...  BoboBong - ... -Final Fantasy. -People with swords. -(starting) People with guns. -Cartoon Porn (J/K) ...  Cartoon: Guns and crime prevention - Ambrosia Software, Inc. web board - ... gun control (I believe people should be able to have ... If the people can not be armed then they ... the horse. People have the right to own guns irregardless of ...  Web Comics and Comic Strips Free Online Comics - ... Marty Bucella’s Cartoon of the Day by Marty Bucella (# 6) ... Past Expiry Cartoon by Johnny Ancich. Jul 4 ...  deviantART: 80skids: Journal - Art - community of artists and those devoted to art. Digital art, skin art, themes, wallpaper art, traditional art, photography, poetry / prose. Art prints.  disinformation | take ‘em out in one shot: ted nugent’s cartoon hunting and narcissism - The gateway to the underground - news, politics, conspiracy and weirdness. ... loses its value. People would just as soon use the ... out and train with our guns—but I see a ...  true majority - [...]

Cartoon People With Guns on November 4, 2005 at 09:12 pm
Page 1 of 1        

Post a Comment


Before commenting, please recite:

Grant me the serenity to ignore the trolls,
the courage to debate with honest opponents,
and the wisdom to know the difference.

Name   
Email   
URL   
Human?
  
 

Upload Image    

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Note: Notifications will only be sent to confirmed email addresses.