Public Schools Admit That They Didn’t Push Gifted Programs Because They Didn’t Want To Promote Eliti

And that’s socialism for you. Nobody can have any more than anyone else, and so everyone gets dragged down to the lowest common denominator.

As many as three-quarters of state schools are failing to push their brightest pupils because teachers are reluctant to promote ‘elitism’, an Ofsted study says today.
Many teachers are not convinced of the importance of providing more challenging tasks for their gifted and talented pupils.
Bright youngsters told inspectors they were forced to ask for harder work. Others were resentful at being dragooned into ‘mentoring’ weaker pupils.

Put another way, there was a tax on smart students and they were forced to redistribute their intelligence to less intelligent students. They were held back out of a sense of equality.
Now ask yourself, is that fair? Is it fair to hold back our brightest and most accomplished students in order to promote equality for other students? And if you don’t think that’s fair, then ask yourself if it’s fair to hold back our most productive and successful citizens in general with exorbitant taxes and wealth redistribution schemes in order to create equality with others.

Tags: , ,


«
»
  • http://Array puhsitch

    The best and brightest will do the majority of their learning outside of the classroom, anyway. Really, what their parents do is more important than what their teachers do.

  • sayanything-2

    The equality of socialist ideology, drag all down to the bottom.

  • puhsitch

    Ah, yeah, competition would be a very good thing!

    With the time and resources thing, it can be hard to convince someone who doesn’t work in a school, but it’s true. There are some crappy schools with crappy teachers and administrators, but I see good ones every day who are coming in early, staying very late, and still struggling to manage everything that they need to do.

  • I don’t like today’s GOP

    So now the schools are creating Republicans? Can’t you be consistent in your rants?

  • sayanything-4204

    ……hey, Obama’s school records from his various college trysts have never been released…..

    could it be, even after holding back the top level’s of his classmates, he still couldnt even make the median grade level……

    using the lefts global warming science methods…….I’d say that fact is settled…..and he is about as intelligent of a Liberal as one can find

    Liberalism….why learn anything….when ignorance is free

  • JoAnn

    Ignoring the gifted hurts everyone. By bringing the brightest down to the average level, they are hurting the US’s ability to compete in the global market. We need the brightest to be challenged…so they can grow up and discover new medicines, new technologies, etc. If we continue to dumb down our best students, we’re ALL in trouble.

    But then again, that is why I home school. My local school wanted to teach my then 5 year old, reading 2nd grade chapter books, her ABC’s. I don’t see them teaching my 7 year old prealgebra this year, either. But that’s what he’s ready for and what he’s getting at home.

  • puhsitch

    This is definitely nothing new. Even the best teachers sometimes need to make a decision between putting effort into the kids who are falling behind and putting effort into enriching the kids who are already ahead. Those who use “elitism” as a reason are silly — but that’s not socialism…just lazy thinking. And the fact is that the gifted kids will have high-achieving outcomes in the long run regardless.

    If we want to ensure higher differentiation of instruction, though, states will need to give more funding for gifted education rather than expect classroom teachers to come up with multiple curricula.

  • sayanything-1714

    Yikes, that’ll teach me to blog while in air.

    In air???? How about blogging while stupid???

  • sayanything-3960

    Didn’t Pushed

    Officially you didn’t have to worry about the gifted program.

  • sayanything-3960

    But I’m sure you’ve never made a mistake Lioncourt. Since you’re so brilliant and wow us with your solid grasp of all things legal on a regular basis.

    No I just thought it was funny that it came up in a post about gifted education.

  • puhsitch

    Well, nothing comes for free. We don’t necessarily need more money, though…better-managed money is more like it. Ultimately, if good teachers can’t do the job they want to do because they don’t have the time/resources, there’s a problem there.

    I don’t think I know what you mean about tying the funding to the students, though. Are you talking about charging tuition?

  • sayanything-9974

    Nobody will subplant you – you are among the elite when it comes to displaying stupidity, ignorance and intolerance. Stupid is as stupid does.

  • sayanything-2

    Where is all your proof that Christians are using terrorism to force people to convert to Christianity, whiny lying c%nt?

    It ain’t over to you prove the sh*t you spew.

  • sayanything-342

    Everytime the public schools promote AGW they are promoting “Eliti”.

  • sayanything-2

    There you go, Wing Chun Geologist, if that really is your name, spewing your divisive, racist hate!

    Just wanted to save all the leftarded morons the trouble of thinking. We know how much that makes their heads hurt!

  • robert108

    Typical Marxist rationalization for suppressing individual achievement.
    It explains the consistent murderous failure of Marxist states.

  • sayanything-101

    “Many teachers are not convinced of the importance of providing more challenging tasks for their gifted and talented pupils.” The teachers are lazy.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    I think you need to proof read your comments for coherence.

    And maybe realize that using big words doesn’t make you smart.

    And I don’t base everything on making money. I say do what makes you happy. My problem is people like you who expect the rest of us to subsidize your lifestyle.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    It wasn’t just their accents. It was the content.

    They sounded…kind of like you. Confused. Incoherent. Not really sure what’s going on.

  • sayanything-453

    Funny! Here in California Both my kids attended a program a program called GATE: Gifted And Talented Education.
    They we being pulled out of regular classes to attend a higher level of English and Math.

    GATE

    OMG! A little digging and I found out that New York has one.

    Gifted and talented in NYC

  • sayanything-81

    When you make a mistake, there’s an excuse. But when inner city high school kids don’t speak with the same accent as you, then they’re stupid.

    Sure.

  • sayanything-7743

    “Is it fair to hold back our brightest and most accomplished students in order to promote equality for other students?”

    While I am not positive, I am willing to bet that they are not holding back the best and brightest students in India, China, Japan, South Korea, etc. I seems like the leftards, big-ed, teachers unions are bent on destroying this country’s economic future.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    Oh how materialist of you.

    I doubt you earn your own way in the world, but supposing you’re telling the truth…you just jumped all over me for my expectation that people provide for themselves.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    And for everyone one of those there are ten who think every problem can be solved with them getting a raise and more paid time off.

    Not saying there aren’t good teachers, but the American public education system has a major performance problem and a serious credibility gap.

    Here in North Dakota teacher pay is online. sunshineonschools.org

    What I see there are teachers who make more than the average North Dakotan while working 2/3′s of the time and graduating kids who need remedial courses before they can take college level classes.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    I’d tend to agree with that. My point was to illustrate how yet again the big government mentality drags everyone down to the lowest common denominator. What could be an opportunity to drive these kids harder breaks down because some have an aversion to recognizing that there are winners and winners in the world.

    Equality of opportunity. Not equity of outcome.

  • sayanything-256

    Agreed. Benefits of special education programs for gifted pupils are probably minimal anyway. Gifted people tend to succeed despite their schooling, not because of it.

  • sayanything-81

    Dude.

    Keep making fun of kids and making excuses for yourself. It’s pretty funny when, after that, you call other people confused and incoherent.

    Too bad you run a blog where 5 or 6 of us whacknips can battle what, 400, of you right wing tards? And consistently put your panties in a knot?

    Heh.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    You’re like the class clown who doesn’t get that everyone else isn’t laughing with you.

    You think you win arguments here? My goodness, kid. I thought you were just a troll.

  • sayanything-81

    Your fallacy Rob, is basing all or your normative standards around making money. I don’t think you actually agree with AV. He’s talking about intellect. You are just talking about potential for material worth. You are reductionist/deflationist about learning where I doubt AV is.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    Yikes, that’ll teach me to blog while in air.

    But I’m sure you’ve never made a mistake Lioncourt. Since you’re so brilliant and wow us with your solid grasp of all things legal on a regular basis.

  • sayanything-81

    I don’t expect anyone to subsidize my lifestyle. I work and have since I could.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    In talking about vouchers and school choice. Make the teachers and schools compete for students.

    And I have a hard time believing that teachers/administrators lack time and resources. They don’t. They just don’t use them properly.

  • sayanything-1641

    As a nation we spend about 100 times as much to remediate goof-offs as we do to offer advanved training to students who want to use their time wisely.

    Consider this…the cost of a high school student repeating a class they failed runs between $800 and $900. That’s the cost to the state. I have about $32,0000 worth of kids taking science from me as seniors because they failed as juniors.

    Additionally the district offers classes in study skills, zero period to make up lost units, and after school tutoring to help these kids get caught up and pass the high school exit exam (a test requiring a 7th grade level of proficiency).

    Here’s a kicker. To a person, each on of these kids is well known to the discipline office, and have probably failed multiple classes because they were disruptive and/or refused to work.

    Because of this particular group of students, the school has to have a full time teacher overseeing an OCS (on campus suspension) room. So there’s an entire teacher’s salary that goes for nothing but temporarily housing kids who are too disruptive for their teachers.

    It’s safe to assume that this minority of students are responsible for most if not all vandalism.

    When you add up the costs of retaking previously failed classes, going to OCS, vandalism, tutoring, and credit make up, the cost of educating a poorly behaved students can easily be twice what it costs to educate an honor student or GATE student.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    On air.

    Sorry. The sometimes the blackberry spell correct is a pain.

  • sayanything-7406

    That’s true. Albert Einstein being a famous example.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    Jeez, it never ends. We already spend more on education than every other nation in the world, but the minute someone points out teachers doing a substandard job we get the “we need more money” refrain.

    Total garbage.

    What we need to do is tie the funding to the students and let them be in control of their education.

Create a SAB Readerblog


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Blog Advice and Support
Installs and Upgrades
Theme Modifications
Custom Plugins
Theme Design
Conversions and Relocations
Hacked Site Recovery
Mobile Apps Development