North Dakota Democrats Want To Punish Insurance Company For Speaking Out Against Obamacare

Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Dakota, like many insurance companies across the nation, does not like what it’s seeing in the Democrat health care bill in Washington DC. So the company has been communicating its concerns with the public. And Democrats in North Dakota don’t like that and are threatening the company with legislative and regulatory action if they don’t pipe down.
After all, it’s not like this is a free country or anything.

BISMARCK, N.D. (AP) A North Dakota state senator says recent Blue Cross Blue Shield opposition to some aspects of health care reform may prompt a response in the Legislature.
Bismarck Sen. Tracy Potter and Fargo Democratic Sens. Tom Fiebiger and Tim Mathern objected to a Blue Cross letter to policyholders about federal health care reform proposals. Fiebiger and Mathern met with company officials Friday.
The letter opposed any so-called “public option” for health insurance that would be run by the federal government. It said the federal health care package will force private insurance rates to rise.
The senators asked Blue Cross about the cost of the mailing.
Blues spokeswoman Denise Kolpack says it cost almost $22,400 for almost 216,000 letters. She says the cost was kept down because for most customers, the material was included in a regular required mailing.
Potter says the senators will consider drafting new disclosure rules for the Fargo health insurer.

What’s a little pathetic is that Republicans, including Insurance Commissioner Adam Hamm, opened this door by kicking off a crusade against BCBS over executive compensation. And these are the sort of problems we create when we accept as legitimate government efforts to question and control spending and compensation at private companies.
Private companies are private. What they pay their employees is private. What they charge their customers is private. And if the company wants to oppose or support certain government policies, again that’s private.
The government has no business getting involved any more than the government has any business getting involved with the price of milk and bread.

Tags: , , ,


«
»
  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    I’d missed it until this evening. Didn’t have as much time as I usually do to peruse the headlines.

    Ticks me off. Those concerned with limited government should make a big stinking deal about this.

  • sayanything-22

    Thanks for posting on this, Rob. I think it is shameful that Potter and Mathern would have the audacity to tell a company (owned and operated by ND policy holders) what they can and can not say about a political issue. It's damn near Orwellian.

  • Tim Mathern

    I have been a member of Blue Cross Blue Sheild for over 50 years. I attended BCBS meeting today and made three points 1. Focus the mission to health care for all. 2. Seek additional efficiencies. 3. Open the Board member selection process.

    I made no threats of punishment.

    Senator Tim Mathern

  • brenarlo

    They should focus on making their customers happy. That is generally done by producing a superior product at a price people are willing to pay. They have no obligation to cover everyone… no obligation to cover people they don't want to. They are a PRIVATE company.

    Of course… the more people they do cover… the lower the premiums are, the happier their customers will be.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    The article refers to Senator Potter threatening regulatory action.

    As a member of BCBS you've got a voice in what the company does. But as a Senator, Tim, it's really none of your business.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    I think that when a business sees legislation coming down the pipe that will impact them they should be able to speak out without fearing retaliatory action from politicians.

  • sayanything-22

    Senator Mathern, a AP aritcle in the GF Herald indicated that because of the letter that NDBCBS sent out expressing their concerns about national heath care policy, you and Sen Potter were considering legislation targeting them. Is this not true?

    <blockqoute> By: Associated Press,

    BISMARCK — A North Dakota state senator says recent Blue Cross Blue Shield opposition to some aspects of health care reform may prompt a response in the Legislature.

    Bismarck Sen. Tracy Potter and Fargo Democratic Sens. Tom Fiebiger and Tim Mathern objected to a Blue Cross letter to policyholders about federal health care reform proposals.

    The letter opposed any so-called "public option" for health insurance that would be run by the federal government.

    Potter says the senators are asking Blue Cross to disclose how much the mailing cost. He says once that information is known, the senators will consider drafting new disclosure rules for the Fargo health insurer.

    Blue Cross Blue Shield has been criticized for misspending money on luxury trips for sales people and severance packages for executives. Potter says many policyholders considered the mailing a waste of money.</blockqoute>

    Italics indicate the quote I refer to.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    Though we're on opposite sides of the political spectrum, Senator Mathern, I respect you a great deal and have always found your openness and transparency refreshing. That being said, this is akin to someone getting a tax audit because they wrote a letter to the editor.

    This has no place in American politics.

  • http://Array farm4money

    tim, how old are you? If you truely have been a member of bcbs for over 50 years and were 18 when you became a member, you would be 68 or older. I didn't think you were that old.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport
  • farm4money

    Hey tim, if you tell little lies, do you tell big lies too???? bought your first policy at 8 or 9 years old did you ???? oh yea ……. your a democrat, it is ok to be loose with the truth

  • sayanything-279

    exactly

  • sayanything-6955

    And BCBS has every right to tell its customers what is coming! http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704…

    I posted a shorty in the reader blogs yesterday when I saw that junk from Potter too, although not as well said as yours boss.

  • Tim Mathern

    I got BCBS as a child, I am 59. I still remember it was a family decision to join as it meant what seemed like a lot of money going out per month when we sort of took care of most medical things at home.. two parents, 13 children and going was tough.

    I do not lie but as I look at the posts I should have said "covered" for over 50 years, there probably is a technical definition that relates to 18 or 21 or when the Blues mutualized. Sorry, my mistake.

    Blues can write letters-my premium dollars were used is my point.

    Main points remain the same.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    And I agree that as a policy holder you've every right to weigh in on how BCBS spends its money.

    But according to Potter you guys are threatening regulatory action. That's wrong, Senator Mathern, no two ways about it.

  • sayanything-3174

    Tell me Senator, why did the NRA give you an F rating while you were running for Gov? I was going to ask you that very question when you were on Joel's radio program but that lefty partisan kept me on hold because he wanted to protect you from 2nd Amendment supporters.

  • sayanything-43

    Imagine that BCBS doesn't want your buddies in Washington to ruin our health care.

    Who should we listen to experts who know what they're talking about or politicians that screw up everything they touch?

  • J Richardson

    It isn't on the BCBS of ND that is being targeted by Democratic state legislators for speaking out. In my home state of North Carolina, 20 Democratic state legislators have asked the Attny General and Insurance Commissioner to investigate BCBS of NC for speaking out and mailing a postcard to their members on the issue.

  • ted wilson

    Senator Matheson,

    Last I looked we do have health care for all or is ND the only state in the Union that turns away people from their Er doors? If you mean primary health care for all, why is that a private insurance company's concern?

    Wouldn't the easiest way be to address the concerns of those small amount (percentage wise) that don't have insurance instead of blowing up the whole system for everyone? I agree that doesn't give politicians as much control over the resulting huge amounts of payoffs, buyoffs, graft, etc as would be available the other way but if you were concerned about truly saving money and making the system better that would be the way to go.

    On a national scale, destroying a system that is sufficient for 280 million Americans because about 15 million Americans don't have it (approx 15 million Americans are eligible but don't sign up OR can afford it but don't purchase; another 15 million are illegals- do you feel your constituents taxes should pay taxes for illegals??) is non-sensical. Reform Medicare in ND, make it run efficiently and then come back to us.

  • Gmama

    This is infuriating, rates will rise for those of us who purchase insurance privately. My family will have to purchase a policy we don't want because Big Brother Government thinks we should. According to the CBC our rates will go up about $600 per month, and because my husband runs a small business and I work for a small business we have had some tough years. Frankly we are just making ends meet, there isn't $600 left over at the end of the month. We are perfectly happy with the coverage we have. So with the democrats disaster of universal coverage our taxes and insurance rates will go up, and we'll go under but we'll have addiction and mental health coverage. God I hope these morons get voted out in 2010.

  • Mr. Jefferson

    Timmy obviously doesn't know his place. BCBS should have told him to eff-off and go pound sand. If the little fascists are this bad just trying to get this abomination passed then just wait until they are running the thing and your access to health care depends on your political views just as now your ability to speak out depends on whether you support the government position. No one is trying to intimidate companies who are in support of ceding control of the health care system to the least able and least ethical amongst us… the government and politicians. No one in the government is threatening retaliation through legislation against those companies.

    And people wonder how fascism ever spread in Europe when we have Timmy and his ilk here.

  • orbicularioculi

    I am not a resident of ND, but you folks have the same problems we all do and that is Politiskunk Professional Politicians like the Senator who believe he KNOWS better than the taxpayers of your state. Best advice. Vote him out of office ASAP!

  • Diane

    I wish you as concerned about the waste in government spending as you are on a private companies spending. You are free to change insurance if you don't like how they're spending your premium dollars. Is was only a letter for heaven's sake!!!

  • sondra

    North Dakota keeps losing its' population, the so called representatives wont have to worry about
    the insurance situation, and they wont have to worry about having political jobs.
    The only thing ND might have is a remote oil shale refinery. Maybe.

  • MikeinAppalachia

    sondra-Nope! "Cap and Trade" will put an end to any kind of oil from shale

  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    We have oil you pump out of the ground rather than being locked up in

    shale.

  • sfcmac

    Hey Tim,

    Newsflash: The private health care industry along with their clients, are justifiably concerned over the government threat to health care choice in this country. They sent out letters to their policy holders outlining those concerns and once again, you Democrats took it upon yourselves to intimidate a business for not kowtowing to Obama’s party line.

    It’s ludicrous for you to squawk over $22,400, when you’re part and parcel to the multi-trillion dollar ObamaCare train wreck.

    No one except the involved parties know what transpired in the meeting, but I hope the Blue Cross officials told all three of you to go to hell.

  • Senator Tim Mathern

    My comments to BCBS were respectful, their comments to me were respectful. My goal is that all people have health care coverage including people in this comment stream. Senator Tim Mathern

  • sayanything-1118

    "Blues can write letters-my premium dollars were used is my point."

    Um… So what you're saying is that you have a right to object to someone using the money you've paid them for a service to express their corporate position on something? What's next? If you're furniture store were to send out the same letter to it's customers, would you be threatening them with legislation? How about Ford? Chevy? The local butcher?

    You have every right to take your business elsewhere, Sen. Mathern. If you don't like the way they are doing business, there is at least one other place in ND that you can get health insurance.

    Also, how come we're not threatening legislation for all of the other groups and industries that are sticking their noses in this? AARP? Farmers Union? Each of those take premiums or membership fees and are using those fees to spew their pro-health care bill bull around…

  • sayanything-1118

    I disagree. In a free market, he has the choice to go elsewhere if BCBS spends their money in what he sees as an unwise fashion.

    As a BCBS policy holder, I have a contract with them to pay a portion of certain medical bills. Them sending out a letter telling me about how my rates may increase because of certain legislation is within that contract as I see it.

    Also, that premium money is a payment for the contract, not for membership or whatever. If my premiums go up and I feel the value is not right, I can move to Medica. Once that money passes to BCBS, as a private company, it's theirs to do with what they want. As long as they aren't spending more than they can afford and running short on paying out medical bills…

  • Consistency not Hypo

    Senator Mathern,

    Farmers Union is placing ads on the radio supporting Obamacare. Radio ads are more costly than a mailing (sorry FLAG). Will you please be consistent and take legislative action against them?

    Blue Cross is an insurance company not a healthcare provider. We all have healthcare.

  • Consistency not Hypo

    Senator Mathern,

    Listen for yourself.
    http://www.ndfu.org/healthcarereform/

Create a SAB Readerblog


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Blog Advice and Support
Installs and Upgrades
Theme Modifications
Custom Plugins
Theme Design
Conversions and Relocations
Hacked Site Recovery
Mobile Apps Development