But the state has issued license plates with religions messages, meaning the state seems to be applying a double standard.
A Fargo man says the state has violated the separation of church and state by rejecting ISNOGOD for his personalized license plate.
In an appeal letter to the state’s Department of Transportation director, Brian Magee said the state has allowed other vehicles to carry plates with religious messages, including PRZZGOD, ILOVGOD and TRI GOD, which he included photos of.
“(I)f the state only allows one point of view on religion to be expressed on its property (the license plates), then it is an endorsement of that point of view,” Magee wrote.
Transportation Director Francis Ziegler is out of the office until Monday, according to his office. Department spokeswoman Peggy Anderson said the request is in review and a decision will be made in a few days.
State law leaves approval up to the discretion of the Motor Vehicle Division. According to department documents, requests must include the meaning of the characters.
Anderson said the division rejects applications that are vulgar, hostile or prejudicial; advocate violence or lawlessness; provoke a violent response; refer to illegal drugs; or incite lust. When questionable applications are submitted, she said, a panel reviews them.
Though there is no actual “separation of church and state” mentioned anywhere in our state or federal constitutions, I agree with Magee that the state is wrong to reject his request of a license plate with an atheist theme. All religious beliefs should be treated equally under the law. But what bothers me about Magee’s goal in all this isn’t that he wants more freedom to pick a license plate message of his choosing, but rather that his goal is to limit the freedom to pick religious messages:
Magee proposes two solutions in his letter: the approval of his license plate application or the recall of plates with a religious point of view. He said he would prefer if the state chose the recall option.
So what Magee wants is less freedom. Not more. Which makes Magee every bit as intolerant and dogmatic as those who are opposing his atheist-themed license plate message.
Which is a criticism I often have of atheists. They aren’t seeking freedom for their religious point of view (or, more accurately, lack thereof) but rather the suppression of other religious points of view.
And, speaking as an atheist myself, that’s wrong.