New York Times: Opposition To Illegal Immigration Is Racism

Silly, loaded rhetoric:

The Nativist reaction of the early 20th century started with a similar virulence. In the aftermath of World War I, “there was just this fear that millions of people were going to pour in,” said Mae Ngai, a Columbia University historian. “You could read the discussion from the 1910s and think you were looking at something from today, if you just took out ‘Italians’ and put in ‘Mexicans’ ”
Anti-immigrant sentiment probably did help Herbert Hoover beat Al Smith — a Catholic, like many immigrants at the time — in 1928. But after Congress overwhelmingly passed new immigration restrictions in 1924, the main political fight over immigration occurred not between the parties, but within the Democratic Party, with those who wanted to embrace the Ku Klux Klan battling those who did not. Franklin D. Roosevelt was in the latter group.
Mr. Rauchway, the historian, argues that the ultimate failure of anti-immigrant politics is part of a larger failure of class-based politics in the United States. Running against the rich — or the poor — has rarely worked in this country. Instead, immigrant-bashing has been most successful when it tapped into broader racial fears, as it did in both the 1850s and the 1920s. Notably, the economy was booming in the ’20s.
“As it becomes less and less acceptable to be racist,” Mr. Rauchway said, “immigration is not going to be as politically effective.”

The idea that opposition to illegal immigration = racism is just plain lazy thinking. Do racists oppose illegal immigration? I’m sure they do, but that does not mean that one must be racist to oppose illegal immigration.
For instance, this opponent to illegal immigration actually thinks one good way to help solve it is to make it easier for people from all over the world to immigrate here legally. That’s not exactly a position a racist would have.
There is, after all, nothing racist about expecting people who come to this country to live and work to actually become citizens and fulfill all the obligations and duties which come with that.

Tags: ,


«
»
  • Wing Chun Geologist

    What the NY Times writer doesn’t understand is that previous mass immigrations truly were truly multi-cultural. Immigrants in previous generations included Japanese, Finns, Swedes, Greeks, Italians. And thay came to an America that expected them to accept existing American culture and be assimilated by it.

    Currently, most immigrants come from a handful of Spanish speaking countries, and in huge, and in truly massive numbers. America’s intellectual elites no longer believe in assimilation, so the new immigrants are not being assimilated by mainstream American culture, but rather by culture of America’s underclass (nature abhores a vacuum).

    Because the numbers are so great, residents in some California cities are finding themselves in a state of culture shock. A few years ago they lived in neighborhoods where most residents (including Hispanic residents) spoke English and lived middle-class lifestyles. Now many of their English speaking neighbors have moved away, and been replaced by Spanish speaking residents with a very different lifestyle.

    For instance, a friend of my Wife’s has lived in the same suburban neighborhood for decades. In the last few years the neighbors on both sides of her have been replaced by non-English speakers. And because there are so many adults living in each house, there is no longer any parking available on the street. She cannot invite friend over for a party, because they would be unable to park their car anywhere near her house. She has commented that there’s always guys just hanging out in large unfriendly. This once middle class neighborhood now has drive-bys and cock fights.

    My wife’s friend (a big time libereal by the way)is thinking about moving out of California. She misses simple things like having a single family living in the house next door, being able to talk to her neighbors in English, and have friends come over to visit and be able to park on her street.

    With this influx of immigrants has come massive traffic delays and school overcrowding. Last year during the immigration protests, some “immigrants rights” activists decided to show their clout encouraging immigrants not to go to work or shop. Some local shock jocks decided to devote their show to callers telling about their commutes. Caller after caller talked about how their 2 commute had become a 20 minute commute.

    A school where I worked had originally been built to accomodate 800 students. But the recent immigration waves have upped the student population to 1700 students.

    These are changes that effect the lives of Californians on a daily basis. These are quality of life issues. These changes have left many many Californians stunned.

  • http://magyartruth.blogspot.com/ Chief RZ

    Really? Wanting to enforce laws is racist? How about the Hungarians thrown out that could not get a green card? The Russians? The NYT has gone completely irrational and communist at the same time. Words-speak 1984.

  • WOOFX

    If you want to Know where the Foreign born are from go here.
    2004 Census
    Approx 1/2 Latin America

  • WOOFX

    If your neighborhood of single family
    homes is being busted up into illegal apts and code enforcement is non existent, your local gov't is in bed with real estate speculators.

  • ollie-B

    Anyone who supports special preferences for illegal immigrants is sadly misguided. Not only do we have illegal immigrants from Latin America, but many from eastern Europe, Africa and the former Soviet Union. The Africans, in larger numbers, seem better at assimilation and speaking English. All illegal aliens are unwelcome in my view. They should be deported immediately and those who persist in hiring illegals should be heavily fined and face jail if necessary. Those who employ illegals keep talking about the high price of goods if they had to hire American workers. Poppycock!! We have the cheapest food costs on the planet. Just how much would a loaf of bread cost us? If we can afford $500.00 Playstations, we can afford $3.00 loaves of bread. All immigrants shoud be able to speak English before citizenship is granted. If you have lived in this country 20 years, you should be able to speak and read English fluently. As far as children born to illegal aliens in this country, the child should not be considered a U.S. citizen unless the mother is working in this country legally and is/or has applied for citizenship. As far as citizenship goes, it is ridiculous to have people who work hard, pay their taxes and do not engage in criminal activity have to wait 7 years before being granted citizenship. Furthermore, I feel that the citizenhip test should be done away with. What does it prove? That you have a good memory? Most of the spies in our country during the Cold War were native born Americans. Hillary says we should help the Latin American countries improve their economies so their people would not feel the need to come here seeking a better life. Bullfeathers!! This is the way many foreign economies work: vast differences between the classes. Now we are going to throw away precious U.S. dollars on a social experiment? No way!

  • Wing Chun Geologist

    I think that a lot of the problems that illegal immigration is causing isn't so much the fault of the illegal aliens. They are simply doing what we Americans are allowing them to do.

    If we required them to learn English, adopt American culture, and live up middle-class expectations of behavior…they would. It's called assimilation and lots of Poles, Italians, Jews, Hatians, Greeks, Finns and Asians have. One of my martial arts teachers came from China not speaking English and mastered the language in a couple years. Another teacher lived in LA and was told by his father-in-law to leave LA so he would have to learn English.

    Previous immigration waves were successful because the governement provided no safety net for immigrants. If you were from Italy and couldn't cut it in Amercia, you went back to Italy. There was no welfare or Medi-Cal.

    They were also successful because they went to schools that only taught them in English, and taught patriotism as part of the school's general curriculum.

    Unfortunately, we don't require that from immigrants today.

  • http://Array richNJ

    I have only one question. I will put it in simple terms for the lovers of the NYT's. If we make 100 new jobs a year and allow 1000 illegal immigrants to enter. We will have a problem. Unless that is what the elite Dimmie's are looking for. Cheap labor to cut their lawns and watch their kids. As I always say "If ignorance is bliss, then I know why most people walk around with a smile".

Create a SAB Readerblog


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Blog Advice and Support
Installs and Upgrades
Theme Modifications
Custom Plugins
Theme Design
Conversions and Relocations
Hacked Site Recovery
Mobile Apps Development