New York Times: Opposition To Illegal Immigration Is Racism
The Nativist reaction of the early 20th century started with a similar virulence. In the aftermath of World War I, “there was just this fear that millions of people were going to pour in,” said Mae Ngai, a Columbia University historian. “You could read the discussion from the 1910s and think you were looking at something from today, if you just took out ‘Italians’ and put in ‘Mexicans’ ”
Anti-immigrant sentiment probably did help Herbert Hoover beat Al Smith — a Catholic, like many immigrants at the time — in 1928. But after Congress overwhelmingly passed new immigration restrictions in 1924, the main political fight over immigration occurred not between the parties, but within the Democratic Party, with those who wanted to embrace the Ku Klux Klan battling those who did not. Franklin D. Roosevelt was in the latter group.
Mr. Rauchway, the historian, argues that the ultimate failure of anti-immigrant politics is part of a larger failure of class-based politics in the United States. Running against the rich — or the poor — has rarely worked in this country. Instead, immigrant-bashing has been most successful when it tapped into broader racial fears, as it did in both the 1850s and the 1920s. Notably, the economy was booming in the ’20s.
“As it becomes less and less acceptable to be racist,” Mr. Rauchway said, “immigration is not going to be as politically effective.”
The idea that opposition to illegal immigration = racism is just plain lazy thinking. Do racists oppose illegal immigration? I’m sure they do, but that does not mean that one must be racist to oppose illegal immigration.
For instance, this opponent to illegal immigration actually thinks one good way to help solve it is to make it easier for people from all over the world to immigrate here legally. That’s not exactly a position a racist would have.
There is, after all, nothing racist about expecting people who come to this country to live and work to actually become citizens and fulfill all the obligations and duties which come with that.



