New Orleans is Gone

A view of New Orleans from Air Force One. David J. Phillip, AP Photo

A view of the flooding in New Orleans, Louisiana from Air Force One August 31, 2005. Authorities struggle to evacuate thousands of people from hurricane-battered New Orleans as food andd water grew scarce and looters create chaos. (David J. Phillip, AP Photo)


I don’t think most people realize that New Orleans is gone. Just gone.
The people who lived there, that part of their life is over.
The ones who are refugees in the city now — like the Superdome residents the past few days — are the poorer class who didn’t have the money or vehicles to make it out of the city. But, most of the middle class and upper class did — in their SUVs and sedans. Most of them packed for a few days — like a camping trip — and they took money out of the ATM and they went to budget motels in northern Louisiana, Mississippi, and Texas to sit out the storm. They are refugees outside the city, waiting to return “home,” but there’s no home to return to.
City officials are forcibly evacuating the city. They won’t let anyone return for a couple of months, while they find and dispose of the thousands of dead bodies. The entire electrical grid is gone, power lines down, 80% of the city is flooded and has been for days. When a structure is flooded like that, usually you have to gut the building and do extensive renovations, but if it’s a one story home (which a lot of homes are), you just condemn it and move on.

Businesses are gone, homes are gone (even if technically still standing at the moment), jobs are gone, schools are gone. The whole economic infrastructure is gone and won’t return in its current form.
Yet, all these people are sitting in these budget hotels at $30 or $40 per night, having to feed their families fast food from the nearest McDonalds, living on their credit cards. But, it’s Labor Day weekend — the traditional start of school…. Money in the checking account is going to run low and you can only live off the credit cards for so long. All these middle class families are going to have to immediately find jobs SOMEWHERE in some town or city, put the kids in school, start re-building their lives, making car payments — finding some place to live.
They can’t wait for two months to go by — and even then, when they are allowed back in the city — they still can’t live there in condemned housing, plus there’s no jobs left nor schools. So, for the next year or two — even if they own property in New Orleans (or have a mortgage on a house), they will have to go live somewhere else. More than likely, they’ll make new friends, get new jobs — and stay. They will not go “back” to New Orleans, because that would actually mean starting over yet again — with yet another job and another move…
We’ve never seen an American city like this evacuated and abandoned. Sure, New Orleans will be re-built. But, it will be something different. It will have different owners, different residents.
When the waters recede, you are going to have lots of worthless building structures — houses, businesses, etc. They say it may be weeks before power is available. But, a city’s economy is a network that feeds off each other. Dry cleaners need customers who want to look nice, restaurants need patrons, bookstores need people with leisurely time, sporting goods stores need people who play in softball leagues… — and those places will not re-build and re-open until they see a profit potential. Yet, the people they need as customers won’t return to live without income — but all the old jobs are gone.
So, what will happen is speculators will buy up large blocks of suddenly devalued land. Maybe undervalued land? And the current “owners” will sell, because what are they going to do with a 1/4 acre where their house used to sit in a devastated neighborhood? The land will be cleared and re-built. And New Orleans will be rebuilt as a resort/casino/water front vacation destination with “historic” appeal. Casinos and hotels will re-build. Luxury high-rise condos will pop up. High-priced “tennis & golf communities” will be developed. Think a combination of Orlando and Las Vegas.
But it will take time. Three or four years ago they did a major renovation of CNN Center and that took a year! That was just one building — think of the scale to re-build an entire city. There’s just not enough construction crews. And initially, it won’t be rebuilt. The insurance companies will just pay off the owners and the buildings will be condemned — while the former residents go live their lives elsewhere, making a living, raising their kids.
Where New Orleans will be “re-built” is when developers swoop in because of the potential for profit — all of that unused land along a warm clime coastal area! Only then will the middle and upper class people will come to New Orleans to work and live, in the new economy of the “new” New Orleans.
That’s 4 or 5 years down the road at best. In the meantime, New Orleans is gone.

Chazz Matthews

Tags:


«
»
  • http://Array Regret

    For consideration:

    We should focus on providing substantial and rapid relief to the victims of Hurricane Katrina, however, as Chazz is doing here, some thoughts should also turn toward the long term.

    A key component of the political compromise that was reached over Federal energy and environmental legislation which was signed into law this past summer was support for the construction of new nuclear power plants. I think that people should consider whether the Katrina tragedy presents an opportunity to connect the gargantuan amounts of federal aid that will flow to the affected region to a commitment of support for the construction of nuclear power plants in the devastated areas.

    As acknowledged in the recent energy and environmental bill, nuclear power deserves our support. However, even nuclear power supporters suffer from NIMBY (not in my back yard) attitudes when it comes to the siting of a new plant.

    After this terrible tragedy, and as Chazz discusses here, we will have large geographic areas that are uninhabitable – and they may be this way for some time. It is an economically and environmentally distressed area, and even if people can move back and reconstruct their homes, what businesses will do the same? We all know that large public works projects will be called for and funded (politicians just love spending the taxpayers money on high visibility stuff), and the combination of these issues leads to an opportunity to advance the nuclear power cause.

    I think we should use some of these public funds, in conjunction with private money, to help build modern nuclear power plants in the New Orleans area. The now-former residents might have the opportunity to find employment during the construction of the facilities, but more importantly, the inexpensive power that would be generated by these plants would draw many power-using businesses to the area, which is necessary for the area to eventually recover.

    The benefits of these new plants would not be felt for many years, but now is a perfect time to get broad support for a plan like this.

  • ChazzMatt

    Exactly.

    I wrote this to friends last Wednesday night and then posted it here Friday morning as what I was saying became ever more apparent. There will be a place CALLED New Orleans, but it’s not going to be the New Orleans city of history. After the water is pumped out, New Orleans will lie as ruins, but I predict will eventually become a casino/condo development/tennis subdivision location with “historic” appeal. Reports say some of the French Quarter was not flooded, so each year you will still have Mardi Gras, the same way Disneyland has their “daily parades.”

    Middle class and upper class people will not return without jobs and schools. And businesses will NOT return until they see a potential for profit (customers). So, real estate development will lead the way, but I think it will take a year to even get the land ready for that (remember, will take up to 4 months for the water to be pumped out).

    New Orleans will return, but different owners, different residents, different type of city. It won’t be as big.

    For instance, you won’t have TV stations or newspapers — at least not like you have now. TV stations and newspapers make their money off advertisers — those ubiquitous car dealers, supermarket ads, mall store holiday sales. For 2005, New Orleans was ranked the #43 market in the nation with 672,000 TV homes. With no advertising income, the TV stations will have to shut down, even if electrical power returrns. Newspapers can’t publish with no customers to buy the paper. All that overhead of salaries and equipment costs money, and there’s no profit potential anymore.

  • ChazzMatt

    explanation: I live in Atlanta, GA which is why I mentioned a specific building that underwent renovation — to compare to the massive effort that all of New Orleans faces. I should have explained that reference better.

  • Andrew

    I’m really worried about where the poor will go. They’re all going to move to surrounding cities and have no money to start over. Many will probably turn to crime, making crime rates significantly rise in the south. Plus, with many of our resources in Iraq and New Orleans, what happens if there is another terrorist attack? America may be facing some pretty challanging times in the near future.

  • richard

    Drew I know that this is not going to go over well but…….I suspect most of them were already commiting crimes in the south.

    Hate to do this as well but G W just had a sound bite on the local news here he was talking to a couple of black guys in front of an American flag and said “it is our job not to be satisfied until the job is done OMG.

    His speach writers probably shit themselves.

  • http://www.longren.org/ tyler

    Excellent post Chazz. The people that got out of the city should start rebuilding their lives as soon as they can.

    I feel so bad for the people that weren’t able to get out. I read comments all the time calling the people that stayed stupid for staying. People don’t realize many people had no way to get out. And even if they did have a way to leave, they had no where to go.

    If I was poor and living in New Orleans, I probably would have stayed too.

    It could get even worse in New Orleans. I just hope the National Guard will be able to restore some order, quickly. If order isn’t restored soon, I fear what may happen. This state of anarchy _could_ spread.

    I know that New Orleans will be cleaned up and rebuilt to some extent. It has to be for the sake of the U.S. economy. New Orleans has/had a huge shipping industry.

  • http://www.moderninstances.com/ moderninstances

    His speach writers probably shit themselves.

    How about when he said that we would “succeed” in rebuilding New Orleans? We already FAILED when there was obviously no plan for evacuating over a hundred thousand of the poorest citizens, it took several days to bring impose order, and there was no organizing force on the ground from day one.

    All the while, the Pres continues his vacation and finds time to play guitar with some unknown country singer. This is just another display of either astounding incompetence or brutal carelessness. Now we’re actually recalling 300 airmen from Iraq and Afghanistan, but the apologists will continue with their delusions about how it doesn’t matter that our “national guard” is deployed abroad.

    If there’s any silver lining that comes out of this, maybe it will be that people in this country will finally come to their senses and we’ll re-evaluate our national priorities.

  • Dave

    I’m really worried about where the poor will go.

    According to the last census, 25% of families in New Orleans are living below the poverty line. So… there are a lot of them.

    I know you guys probably hate Dailykos, but check out this diary: http://dailykos.com/storyonly/2005/9/2/13737/40966

  • Bill

    In my opinion, New Orleans is not only gone now, it’s gone forever.

    The people that left aren’t in suspended state. They are alive. If it takes a year to make New Orleans habitable again, we surely cannot expect some mass influx once we announce “New Orleans is now open again.” Who moves back into a closed city a year later? And if one is able to do that, the odds are one is either very rich or still has nothing a year later. What a setup that would be.

    I suppose some businesses may wish to return, and bring workers with them. But that seems a risky investment, given the city’s geography.

    And why bother doing that? Just so it can flood again like this? Just because of the French Quarter? It’s a waste of effort. The city is in a bad location. Don’t rebuild there again.

    I can see New Orleans being a port, with docks and such and some shipping infrastructure. But not a city every again. I don’t get it.

  • keep it simple

    His speach writers probably shit themselves.

    his speach writers love it. It keeps sentiment of responsibility on the image of a clown president, not a very serious administration with unbridled power. Survey says people are suckers for superficial crap like that.

Create a SAB Readerblog


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Blog Advice and Support
Installs and Upgrades
Theme Modifications
Custom Plugins
Theme Design
Conversions and Relocations
Hacked Site Recovery
Mobile Apps Development