ND Economic Development Failure

Image and video hosting by TinyPic

Ho Hum, another economic development failure.
Business Week!

Imation Corp. has shuttered its floppy diskette plant in Wahpeton and will transfer ownership of its buildings to the city this week, its spokesman says.
“We are out of the place,” said Brad Allen, an Imation spokesman at the company’s headquarters in Oakdale, Minn…
Imation has received millions of dollars in local, state and federal grants and guaranteed loans to expand its Wahpeton plant. The company plans to transfer ownership of two buildings in Wahpeton to the city on Thursday. One building the company used was owned by the city.

I have to give credit to these economic development guys. They can pick a bad investment everytime.
Millions of dollars spent and nothing to show for it. What kind of economic development WOULD have happened if this money weren’t coerced from the people that earned it to give to this corporate charity.
This investments seem to always turn out wrong. That’s probably why the people of North Dakota made it expressly illegal for any ND government entity (which includes cities, counties etc) to give money to a private business. And with the respect that we’ve come to expect from the government they decided that the state constitution didn’t apply to them if they formed an economic development corporation to do what they are expressly forbidden to do.
The former head of the North Dakota Workers Safety and Insurance agency is going to trial for misappropriation of state property. The are accusing him of giving about $20,000 to employees as non-authorized bonuses.
These Economic Development guys are losing millions and nothing happens to them. Where was that story about North Dakota corruption again?

Tags:


«
»
  • http://Array Socks

    I’m not sure that this could be termed an economic failure. Floppy diskette plant? The very type of plant reveals why they are closing it. Flash drives can give thousands of times more space and there are single gigabyte flash drives available for less than ten dollars. The average size of a floppy disk is a bit less that 2 megabytes. Even rounding up it would take five hundred floppy disks to equal one gigabyte. Supply and demand. New computers no longer have floppy drives, so there is no reason to manufacture floppies anymore. This isn’t economic failure, it’s Imation getting rid of a useless plant that wouldn’t earn them money unless they went back in time.

  • brenarlo

    My guess is that Imation didn’t pay a dime in property taxes.

  • jimmypop

    sorry dude or dudette, while some EDC / state funded private businesses fail, you dont hear crap about all the good things the ND EDCs do. They quietly chug out little and big projects. Look at the tech park by NDSU as a superior example. With the exception of Alien tech that area boomed with the help of EDC. Alien promised 400 jobs paying $65K or something. needless to say….. but I am saying it anyway….. they have 100 that pay $12 per hour and just dumped one of their buildings on NDSU.

    Anyway, the only problem I see with these grants/ gifts is that they dont tie any ‘proof of success’ reporting to the loans or grants. Why dont they? because no other EDCs nation wide do and companies will go where the money and ease of operation is.

    One more note; how much money did Imation and its worker bees contribute to local and state taxes during its short visit to ND? While it sucks they are leaving, I think they gave more than they took.

  • theovermind99

    My guess is that Imation didn’t pay a dime in property taxes.

    However, the people they employed probably did. The people they employed also spent money in the community which helped local businesses.

    It has a spotty track record, at best, and certainly isn’t worth the millions we pour into it.

    But isn’t that the nature of the free market in general. Not all businesses succeed and any investment is a risk. ED is a risk that this state needs to take because companies like imation wouldn’t give ND a second look without it. ED may not be the best solution, but it’s the best one that we have, unless you can think of something else?

  • theovermind99

    But if that’s true, why were the taxpayers being forced to invest in it?

    It’s incorrect to characterize this as taxpayers investing in an old plant that makes products nobody wants. When imation came to ND floppy disks were the norm. Times change and so does technology. The fact remains that when they did come they employed alot of people who helped broaden the tax base and overall put downward pressure on tax rates. Isn’t that what we all want?

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    I’m not sure that this could be termed an economic failure. Floppy diskette plant? The very type of plant reveals why they are closing it.

    Well sure.

    But if that’s true, why were the taxpayers being forced to invest in it?

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    Jimmy, I think if we listed all the successes of ED and all the failures you’d see there is a problem with government-run economic development.

    It has a spotty track record, at best, and certainly isn’t worth the millions we pour into it.

    Point-2-Point
    Websmart
    Imation
    Alien Technology
    LAS International

    I could go on and on.

    All ED projects. All failures.

Create a SAB Readerblog


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Blog Advice and Support
Installs and Upgrades
Theme Modifications
Custom Plugins
Theme Design
Conversions and Relocations
Hacked Site Recovery
Mobile Apps Development