Home ND News Mobile Forum Contact Reader Blogs Register Login

Saturday, December 08, 2007


Mike Huckabee Wanted To Quarantine AIDS Patients

The Associated Press dug back through their archives and found some answers Huckabee gave to a questionnaire they sent him when he was seeking a seat in the House in 1992.  He said some pretty controversial things about the AIDS issue it turns out.  Here’s the three key quotes:

“If the federal government is truly serious about doing something with the AIDS virus, we need to take steps that would isolate the carriers of this plague.”

“I feel homosexuality is an aberrant, unnatural, and sinful lifestyle, and we now know it can pose a dangerous public health risk.”

“In light of the extraordinary funds already being given for AIDS research, it does not seem that additional federal spending can be justified. An alternative would be to request that multimillionaire celebrities, such as Elizabeth Taylor, Madonna and others who are pushing for more AIDS funding be encouraged to give out of their own personal treasuries increased amounts for AIDS research.”

I, personally, don’t feel that homosexuality is all that aberrant or “sinful.”  As long as the participants in a sexual relationship are all consenting adults, I don’t really have a problem with it.

I also think that Huckabee is right in his statement about funding for AIDS research.  To be blunt, AIDS is a behavioral disease.  If you don’t have promiscuous sex and you don’t use intravenous drugs your chances of getting the disease drop to near zero.  Given the number of diseases out there that afflict people regardless of their lifestyle choices, I’m not sure why the taxpayers should foot the bill for AIDS research when that money could be better spent researching other diseases.

But the real problem here is Huckabee’s support for quarantining AIDS patients.  Not only would that be a fantastically egregious violation of individual liberty, it is also completely unnecessary given that AIDS is, again, a behavioral disease.  If you’re not out having sex with strangers all the time and you’re not sharing needles, you won’t get it.  There are instances, of course, of people who know they have AIDS actually trying to give it to other people, but we’re already putting the people responsible for that sort of thing in jail.

So Huckabee couldn’t be more wrong on that point, though I’m not surprised that a big-government nanny stater like him would support that kind of solution.

Does this hurt Huck in the primaries though?  We’ll see, but most of Huck’s support is coming from the evangelicals who aren’t likely to be phased by this sort of thing.  If anything this is going to galvanize dislike for him among the more fiscally conservative elements of the GOP, but they already disliked him.

Update: Jonathan Adler:

Is Huckabee willing to throw the idea of limited government out the window any time there is a plausible (or even not so plausible) public health argument for doing so?  What does it mean when he says it is the government’s “responsibliity” to create a “culture of health,” and that there should be federal legislation pushing employers encourage healthier lifestyles among their employees?  It is often noted that Huckabee brings the fervor of a convert to health issues because of his own health turnaround — and that is what worries me.

Me too.

Does this tick you off? Click here to email your elected representatives right here on Say Anything, or comment below.

Comments

It is up to Fred Thompson and the other Republican candidates to expose Huckabees true record, one of them must close the sale.

We’ll see, but most of Huck’s support is coming from the evangelicals who aren’t likely to be phased by this sort of thing.

Evangelicals are not part of the ignorant unwashed masses incapable of making decisions on the whole man. At this point in time on Christian issues Huckabee is making the right sounds, Fred and others need only assure Evangelicals they care about the same issues.


In keeping silent about evil, in burying it deep within us, so that it appears nowhere on the surface, we are implanting it, and it will rise up a thousandfold in the future.
Alexander Solzhenitsyn. The Gulag Archipelago

Neiman on December 8, 2007 at 12:18 pm

I imagine Huckabee’s answer seemed a lot less radical in 1992 in an Arkansas context. If you read the histories of early AIDS in the United States(Randy Shilt’s book, for example) you’ll see one of the big public policy errors was the inability or unwillingness to address the AIDS crisis as a public health crisis. Bath houses stayed open, etc.

And you know how you were unhappy with Hoeven’s (staff) answers to your questions last month? This story shows you why politicians tend to answer questionnaires and the like in weasely fashions. If you’re honest, sooner or later, honest answers will be used against you. Lots of groups on both sides—but mostly the left - prepare questionnaires for sole purpose of “gotcha.”

A gutsy politician would say, no, I’m not filling out your forms, ANY forms.

Pomerdorgrad on December 8, 2007 at 12:22 pm
Avatar for Paul

To be blunt, AIDS is a behavioral disease.

Yes, but that’s also true of heart disease, emphysema, lung cancer, diabetes, liver failure and vehicular trauma, among other things.

I’ll gladly join you in calling for an end to federally-funded research into cures for behaviorally-induced illness, provided we apply the prohibition across the board.

Of course, we shall have to inform your readers who smoke, drink, eat high-fat diets, or read blogs in lieu of exercising that there may not be a cure for the diseases likely to ail them.

Paul on December 8, 2007 at 12:46 pm
Avatar for Bill Mitchell

Lol, does this hurt Huckabee in the primaries?

Well, he definitely loses the gay vote, but other than that, no.  Most evangelicals believe exactly as he does, that homosexuality is a sin and the Bible says as much.

I think this hurts him zero, but in this weird election cycle, you never know.

Bill Mitchell on December 8, 2007 at 01:28 pm
Avatar for Bill Mitchell

The BEST part of all this from Romney’s standpoint is that he gets to play underdog in Iowa and a “come-from-behind” win will actually have some ‘gravitas’ instead than winning by 20 because he ‘bought’ the state.

With a month left, the press, which bores easily, really have run out of nice things to say about Huckabee.  All they have left is to dish some dirt to keep things interesting.

Huckabee gets the bullseye instead of Romney.  Who knows, his surge may be just what Romney needs.  Like I said, in this weird campaign cycle, we’ll just have to wait and see.

The one thing I do know is that NOBODY and I mean NO-BODY is talking about Giuliani AT ALL.

People are making a big deal about Thompson going ALL IN in Iowa.  Well averaging about 10 points in the polls there, he has little chance to win.  However, he can play spoiler to Huckabee by beating him up 24/7 and only Romney benefits.

We’ll see.  It should be quite a show.

Bill Mitchell on December 8, 2007 at 01:34 pm

“there should be federal legislation pushing employers encourage healthier lifestyles among their employees”

This translated means that you won’t be able to get a job unless you live up to what the Feds decide is an acceptable lifestyle. They’ll be handing out tax credits to those employers who establish a work force that tows the line.

Geeze. The road to serfdom is a viral one. When did it become the business of the Feds through the employers to get into the middle of our lifestyles? The objective is for the Feds and the employers to replace the church and the family. Sound familiar?

ews48 on December 8, 2007 at 02:17 pm
Avatar for alexia

My favorite part is where Tax Hike Mike said, in his November statement, that he would double President Bush’s AIDS spending from 15 billion to 30 billion. I thought conservatives were supposed to believe in cutting expenses.

Thompson can do damage to Huckabee in the south too. In fact, he’s probably in the best position to do that since he is also from a southern state.

alexia on December 8, 2007 at 02:33 pm

Finally! A point of intelligence from Democrat Huck.


Una Salus Victus Nullam Sperare Salutem

2Hotel9 on December 8, 2007 at 04:39 pm

Huck’s already lost my vote on issues like his being soft on immigration and being a tax-and-spender, but on this issue Huck is spot-on. 

Good on him, I say, but I’d still prefer a Thompson / Tancredo / Hunter ticket.


...for great justice

Whether they are defending the Soviet Union or bleating for Saddam Hussein, liberals are always against America. They are either traitors or idiots, and on the matter of America’s self-preservation, the difference is irrelevant.” —Ann Coulter, P. 16

http://i44.tinypic.com/t89p3s.jpg[/IMG]”] t89p3s.jpg

2qu7zgw.jpg

AMERICANS FOR TRUTH

NO PRIDE. LV

MASS RESISTANCE

THE PINK SWASTIKA

Move_Zig on December 9, 2007 at 12:31 am

Have none of you read about Typhoid Mary?

Before the transmission vectors were well understood, HIV/AIDS had the potential to become a pandemic.  Had the HIV virus ever developed an airborne vector (see Bubonic and Neumonic Plague), the consequences would have been dire for humanity.  A strict quarantine implemented once reliable testing was available would have either stopped or severely reduced the spread of HIV/AIDS, saving thousands of lives.

Should a repeat of the Spanish Influenza (based on something akin to Ebola or HN51 Asian Bird Flu in terms of lethality and via an airborne vector from human to human) arise, strict quarantine and mandatory inoculation (assuming such an inoculation can be created in time) would be the only means of arresting the spread of the disease.  Failure to stop the spread would result in a 20-50% die off of the productive populations of modern nations and a nearly universal die off in less developed nations.


Out Here
Rodney G. Graves
(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

Ceterum censeo Parthia esse delendam
Latin: “Furthermore, Parthia (Persia aka modern day Iran) should be destroyed.”

Rodney Graves on December 9, 2007 at 02:01 pm
Page 1 of 1        

Post a Comment


Before commenting, please recite:

Grant me the serenity to ignore the trolls,
the courage to debate with honest opponents,
and the wisdom to know the difference.

If you want to ignore a fellow commenter, download this.

Name   
Email   
URL   
Human?
  
 

Upload Image    

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Note: Notifications will only be sent to confirmed email addresses.

    

By submitting your comment you agree to our terms of service.