Liberal Blog Uses Paul Ryan’s Dead Father As A Talking Point
(Washington Examiner) — At the age of 16, Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wis., suffered the death of his 55-year-old father. Because of his father’s early death, the government made survivor payments for a few years to Paul Ryan’s family – including for Paul Ryan himself. Ryan collected benefits for two years, until he turned 18.
The net effect of the death of Paul Ryan’s father was likely to reduce taxpayer expenditures on Ryan’s family, since retirees typically collect at least a decade’s worth of benefits. (My own father died five years short of retirement. The result was that my mother, who could otherwise have collected spousal benefits when he retired, instead had to wait well over a decade for benefits, reducing her lifetime social security benefits. She was effectively punished for his death.)
But the Daily Kos blog is now using his father’s early death against Ryan. A Daily Kos diary attacks Ryan in a post entitled, “Entitlement-hating Paul Ryan collected Social Security benefits until he was 18.” Never mind that Ryan’s recent budget proposal doesn’t in fact seek to abolish entitlements, much less get rid of Social Security. It merely seeks to cut the rate of growth of exploding Medicare costs by eventually giving its recipients vouchers they can use to shop around for medical care.
Not all Daily Kos diaries reflect the views of Daily Kos as a whole, but this one does, since it was briefly featured on the top of the front page of Daily Kos, and is still listed as a “recommended” blog post in the sidebar on the right side of Daily Kos’s main page. More than 183 Daily Kos readers have commented in response to it – virtually all in agreement with its hateful sentiments.
The real problem here, as the liberals who use variations of this talking point always fail to mention, is that paying into these entitlement programs isn’t optional. If you don’t like Social Security, if you think Medicare is a scam, there’s nothing you can do. You pay into the programs or you go to jail.
What’s more, after you reach a certain age, you have to enroll in Medicare. There used to be a private insurance market for Americans over the age of 65 to get health insurance, but it no longer exists because seniors don’t have the option of leaving Medicare.
The government has made participation in these programs mandatory, and then the proponents of the programs use the word “hypocrite” to describe those critics who have no choice but to participate.
Make Social Security and Medicare voluntary and then let’s see who the hypocrites are.Tags: deficits, entitlements, medicare, national debt, paul ryan, social security