It’s The Minimum Wage: Teens Having Trouble Finding Jobs, Unemployment Among Young Workers Way Up

The way the Bismarck Tribune explains this, teens and young adults are getting crowded out of entry-level jobs by older Americans who are struggling thanks to the economic downturn. While I don’t doubt that’s part of the problem right now, I think it’s foolish to ignore the role of minimum wage hikes over the last several years.

Blotter’s job hunt began shortly after Christmas, he said, and ended two weeks ago when a movie theater hired him. He applied at Burger King, KFC, McDonald’s and three mall vendors during his search and followed up with each.
“Icalled every one,” he said, “They said, ‘No, you’re not what we’re looking for.’”
National and state numbers hint at the market’s possible fallout for student workers.
National teenage unemployment jumped from 15.8 percent in March 2008 to 21.5 percent this March, according to USAToday.
Job Service North Dakota’s data show a much smaller increase here.
Last March 7.3 percent of all unemployment insurance claimants in the state were younger than 24. In March 2009, that number had risen to about 8 percent.

And keep in mind that those unemployment numbers may be distorted as the youngest workers in our economy don’t qualify for unemployment benefits:

“Keep in mind, many of the persons in the youngest age categories of the labor force are not eligible for unemployment benefits,” Lelan Bosch, communications and marketing specialist for Job Service, wrote in an e-mail.
“They have to meet certain earnings and employment duration criteria to become eligible.”

The economy downturn is driving a lot of this, but what is undoubtedly exacerbating the situation is the drastic increase in the minimum wage over the last several years. By this July, the minimum wage for most areas of the country will have gone up roughly two dollars in about two years. For companies that typically provide entry-level work, that’s a massive inflation in the price of labor. And most companies are no doubt dealing with it by eliminating part-time or entry level positions. Or they’re hiring older, more experienced workers who are worth the higher wages for those positions.
We’re often told that the minimum wage is good for low-wage workers because it gives them a pay raise. The truth is that the minimum wage acts like a tax on low wage labor. By inflating the price of that labor, without doing anything to increase the labor’s value, it simply represents more overhead for businesses. And overhead is dealt with either cost cutting (lay offs, etc.) or increased prices.
In the midst of an economic downturn, neither is helping.

Tags: , , ,


«
»
  • http://www.sayanythingblog.com/ electnixon

    I loved the fast food scenes in American Beauty.

    Lester Burnham: Smile! You’re at Mr. Smiley’s.

    Mr. Smiley’s Manager: I don’t think you’d fit in here.
    Lester Burnham: I have fast food experience.
    Mr. Smiley’s Manager: Yeah, like twenty years ago!
    Lester Burnham: Well, I’m sure there have been amazing technological advances in the industry, but surely you must have some sort of training program. It seems unfair to presume I won’t be able to learn.

  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    Obama is none of those things. All he can manage is to read the teleprompter.

  • http://insanereindeer.blogspot.com/ Kenny

    Reagan cuts taxes; enormous rise in the national debt.

    Massive spending led to increased debt. Strike one.

    Bush cuts taxes; debt doubles.

    After a recession and terrorist attacks spending shoots through the roof. After the 2003 tax cuts revenues catch up to the new spending, and defecits drop. Strike 2.

    Country embraces conservative ecoomic policy; deep recession follows.

    6 years later? Cuase and effect there is not. What nonsense. Dino swings…but the umpire announces no ball has evern been thrown.

    Republicans control country unilaterally for 6 years; debt doubles, financial markets, sector collapse.

    Dino cusses out the umpire when the umpire announces that Republicans have no had complete control of the country ever.

    Dino’s previous swing is counted as a strike and he’s out.

  • badlands4

    Bush takes office; country hit by terror attack nine months later.

    Kobar towers? USS Cole? U.S. embassy bombings in Africa? All before President Bush. Cheap shot, and NO, I am not a Republican, but I believe in fairness in words and thoughts when it comes to both parties, and if you are going to point out one thing, be fair and point out both. Can’t forward a real dialogue or debate if you won’t have intellectual honesty

  • jimmypop
  • Bat One

    Give it up, Swish. You’re just as bad at sarcasm as you are at supposedly fact-based discussions. Best stick to the vile invective and the smarmy, gutter insults. Granted no one takes what you say seriously, but you are demonstrably worse at just about everything things else.

  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    Reagan cuts taxes; enormous rise in the national debt.

    No revenues skyrocket but the dem congress spends even more.

    Greenspan cuts interest rates; destructive housing bubble created.

    The Federal Reserve board has no control over long term interest rates. Duh, mortgages are set by the market.

    Bush cuts taxes; debt doubles.

    Revenues climb, congress (this time Republicans) spends more and debt climbs.

    Country embraces conservative ecoomic policy; deep recession follows.

    Economy soars until Democrats retake Congress in 2006.

    Republicans control country unilaterally for 6 years; debt doubles, financial markets, sector collapse.

    Actually things collapsed after the Dems took the Congress in 2006.

    Bush takes office; country hit by terror attack nine months later.

    By terrorists let in by Bill Clinton. (8 months but that is quibbling.)

    Conservatives pass Prop 13; California declines for decades.

    Because of wild liberalism from the state legislature.

  • Dino2

    Reagan cuts taxes; enormous rise in the national debt.

    Greenspan cuts interest rates; destructive housing bubble created.

    Bush cuts taxes; debt doubles.

    Country embraces conservative ecoomic policy; deep recession follows.

    Republicans control country unilaterally for 6 years; debt doubles, financial markets, sector collapse.

    Bush takes office; country hit by terror attack nine months later.

    Conservatives pass Prop 13; California declines for decades.

    Want more?

  • http://sayanythingblog.com/entry/america_is_back/#c397018 Dino2

    Finally! You people have been waiting for some reason to find fault with a minimum wage! Thankfully we have a deep recession and resulting high unemployment you can blame on the minimum wage!

    Whew! That was close!

    Next up: My jock itch is due to the closing of Chrysler dealerships!

  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    Green jobs, like Barack’s idol, Mr. Green Jeans.

  • jimmypop

    Actually, Dino, I said this very thing would happen befor the minimum wage hikes were ever put in place.

    actually MANY of us did.

    my example was the pizza shop i ran during school. i would HAPPILY keep crew on just in case of a late night rush because they were all getting paid between $5.25 and $6.25 (min wage was $4.25 back then and crew only got pain min for a month or two tops). now, the min wage has doubled….. i know what I would do…. I would cut hours or staff to maintain my profit.

  • Dino2

    No, all 6 million job lost were due to that minimum wage increase.

    I understand the rise in teenage pregnancy and oral sex practice is directly tied to the increase also.

    Just the other day a derivatives trader for AIG told me in confidence that the credit default swap market tanked because of the wage hike.

    My dentist even told me that raising the minimum causes tooth decay.

  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    And higher unemployment does happen every time. George HW Bush raised the minimal wage and we went into a recession as well.

  • Dino2

    Now wait just a minute, stem. You people said the markets tanked last fall in anticipation of an Obama win. Now you tell me the markets can’t respond to the positive effects of having a leader who is lucid, intellectual and whose plans are anticipated to do good things?

    How many ways would you like to have this?

  • Bat One

    My mistake… and apologies. Here’s the link to that NYT article.

  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    Dino probably didn’t notice the story is about teens which means “teenagers.”

  • Dino2

    I just read that the job losses on Wall Street was due to last July’s minimum wage hike.

    Wait a minute, a new story is coming over the wires saying that the job losses in the construction industry are directly linked to the minimum wage hike of last July!

  • Bat One

    DOW up 30% in the past 9 weeks!

    Thank you Barack and your stimulus spending!

    See how this works?

    Not so fast, Swish. According to the NYT Times there has been almost no “stimulus” spending to date:

    Nearly three months after President Obama approved a $787 billion economic stimulus package, intended to create or save jobs, the federal government has paid out less than 6 percent of the money, largely in the form of social service payments to states…

    The stimulus bill has directly injected around $45.6 billion into the economy, mostly to help states cover the costs of Medicaid and unemployment benefits, one-time $250 checks that were mailed to Social Security recipients last week, and income tax cuts that began to take effect this spring…

    When the bill was still in Congress, the need for speed was so important that the Obama administration agreed to funnel much of the money through existing programs to accelerate the process. The bill’s Republican opponents questioned the bill’s short-term effects, seizing on a Congressional Budget Office report that found that much of the spending would be pushed into later years.

    Now, a federal government that has often been caricatured as profligate has begun trying to spend money as quickly as possible and has become fixated, to use the new Washington catch phrase, with “getting money out the door.”

    So here’s the question: How can Obama’s “stimulus” spending be responsible for the economy’s improvement as you’ve noted, if only about $50 billion has been spent?

    On the other hand, if the economy has improved so much that you are trumpeting the results of spending only $50 billion, why should we bother spending the remaining $730 billion, which we don’t have, when the economy is already picking up?

  • robert108

    Yes, and I predicted back in 1980 that adopting conservative economic policies would lead us to ruin.

    You were wrong then, and you are wrong now. If we ever adopt fiscal conservatism, there will never be another recession, and that will be the end of wasteful social spending, excessive taxation, and harmful regulation. In fact, it would reduce the cost of govt considerably, thus leaving more money in the pockets of those who earn it, so it will increase economic justice, as well.

  • robert108

    Finally! You people have been waiting for some reason to find fault with a minimum wage!

    Uneducated little dino: The economic argument against the minimum wage has never changed. It’s bad for the economy and for unskilled workers, by its very nature, and that will never change, no matter how ignorant you are.

  • http://thecynicaleconomist.com/ thecynicaleconomist
  • Dino2

    Found another one!

    A study released today says that if the minimum wage was abolished we’d all be rich, the meltdown would never have occurred and the debt would vanish overnight!

    Wow! You guys were abso-fuckin-lutely correct!

  • Dino2

    Got a call last weekend from an old friend in the Midwest. He was laid off from his six-figure consulting job thanks to the minimum wage increase!

    I also hear that the closing of 1100 Chrysler dealerships and the impending GM bankruptcy are directly the result of the minimum wage. The Mises Institute said so.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com/entry/america_is_back/#c397018 Dino2

    July isn’t recent.

    I understand the wage hike last July led to the housing meltdown, the collapse of Bear Stearns, Lehman, AIG, Countrywide, Indymac, lots of banks and the stock market. Well, that and Barney Frank’s boyfriend.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com/entry/america_is_back/#c397018 Dino2

    Jimmypop:

    actually MANY of us did.

    Source?

    I’ve been dying to do that.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com/entry/america_is_back/#c397018 Dino2

    And I swore that if they closed those dealerships my jock itch would flare up again.

    There was no minimum wage hike recently. The jobs being lost aren’t exclusively MW jobs. The fast food places where I live are closing because they built too many during the boom. Stores are closing because no one wants to buy anything since the republicans made them anxious about their jobs.

    Are you going to tell me the stores and restaurants are closing due to the minimum wage?

  • badlands4

    17 yo daughter is working at one of the state parks for the second straight summer at 9.50 an hour, a .50 an hour raise from last year….the key? She worked hard, did things that were not in her “job description” because they were shorthanded. She didn’t whine about whether some of the things she was doing were in her job description “contract”, she just jumped in to help when needed….in short, she made herself valuable to her employer, and at the end of the season, not only did he write her a glowing letter of recommendation, but he made a point to let the next park manager know about her.

    When she applied this summer, he hired her w/o any qualms, and hired her with a raise.

    My 14 yo son has a reputation as somebody you want to hire to do your summer yard work. He works hard, goes over and above what is agreed to, and gives his all to each job. He makes well above minimum wage…on average 50.00 per yard for about 4 hours work.

    I guess my point is, no matter what job you do, if you make yourself a valuable asset to your employer, you will, MOST OF THE TIME, not all of course, come out on top. If your employer cannot afford to pay you what he/she would like, they will often find other ways to try and show how they value you, and if you are valued, you will be the last one fired and the first one hired, and employers will go to bat for a valuable employee in a heartbeat while they might not lift a finger for a whiny, pain in the rear employee.

    Of course, some employers are just not interested in anything but themselves, BUT employees have an obligation to do their best as well, and often we don’t want to talk about employees who may not be worth the effort or pay.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com/entry/america_is_back/#c397018 Dino2

    George HW Bush raised the minimal (sic) wage and we went into a recession as well.

    That’s an even better example of a logical disconnect. But yet you people don’t see any connection between bush’s (43) wider, more pervasive economic policies and the recent meltdown.

    Clinton raised the MW and those kinds of jobs skyrocketed.

  • Dino2

    DOW up 30% in the past 9 weeks!

    Thank you Barack and your stimulus spending!

    See how this works?

  • robert108

    I understand the wage hike last July led to the housing meltdown, the collapse of Bear Stearns, Lehman, AIG, Countrywide, Indymac, lots of banks and the stock market.

    Wrong again, uneducated litttle dino! It was the Dem social engineers, facilitated by Geithner, Fannie and Freddie and the Dem culture of corruption that is responsible for all that.

  • J.L.

    “Dow up 30%..Thank you for your stimulus sending.” Sure, Dino. That`s about the same as giving your family a new credit card. Look! We get to spend more! But… Anyway, It`s allmost impossible to use rational thought with Dumbo-case in point- he still can`t see the difference between the revenue side and the spending side of economics. Tax cuts always bring in more revenue but, politicians, Dem and Rep., seem to spend more than they take in. So, Dino blames… the tax cuts. Predictable.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com/entry/america_is_back/#c397018 Dino2

    Yes, and I predicted back in 1980 that adopting conservative economic policies would lead us to ruin.

    I was right.

  • http://www.valleydeals.com/cgi-bin/board2/YaBB.pl Kevin

    Not to worry, Obama will give them all cushy government jobs.

  • robert108

    See how this works?

    No, little dino; please explain it to us, using cause and effect reasoning, how anything Obama has done benefits our economy. How has he caused any growth in the stock market?
    Got any specifics?
    Anything to back up your claim?

  • robert108

    Rob: The minimum wage increase of last July is still wreaking damage on our economy, on a month to month basis, and will until or unless it’s repealed.

  • robert108

    Want more?

    What, more examples of your superstitious belief that coincidence equals causality? Or more examples of woefully incomplete information, with no cause and effect connections?

  • http://insanereindeer.blogspot.com/ Kenny

    July isn’t recent.
    I understand the wage hike last July led to the housing meltdown, the collapse of Bear Stearns, Lehman, AIG, Countrywide, Indymac, lots of banks and the stock market. Well, that and Barney Frank’s boyfriend.

    July is recent.

    And as I showed before with month by month stats, teen unemployment shot thru the roof afterwards, jumping more than a percent in a month. By the end of the year, it was up 4%.

    But hell, what do facts matter? Keep blaming Bush and “conservative policies”.

    Yes, and I predicted back in 1980 that adopting conservative economic policies would lead us to ruin.

    Just keep repeating the same bogus lie. Never offer details or specific policies. Just keep blaming Bush and republicans. YAAAWWWWN

  • Bodhi

    When the federal government said I had to pay a higher minimum wage to unskilled employees, it removed any and all incentive for me to pay a lackadaisical kid to do something and forced me to get the most value for my dollar. That means, I have employed motivated adults that do the job, very well, and have subsequently been paid higher wages owing to their hard work and diligence on the job. In a way, the higher minimum wage helped me find better people to do unskilled tasks.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    Just to add to Kenny’s comments, let’s remember that a lot of teen employment is pretty seasonal The proverbial “summer jobs.”

    Thus, some of the impact of last July’s minimum wage hike would be hitting this summer.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    There was no minimum wage hike recently.

    Actually, genius, there was just a minimum wage hike in July of last year and another one is set to go off this July.

    Try knowing what you’re talking about.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    July isn’t recent.

    This coming July will be pretty recent. And a year isn’t long in terms of the national economy.

    As for whether or not I called this, this is what I wrote about the matter a year ago:

    Minimum Wage Goes Up Today, Unemployment Rate For Low Wage Workers To Follow

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    Actually, Dino, I said this very thing would happen befor the minimum wage hikes were ever put in place.

  • Pingback: RealTime - Questions: "If I wrote a letter to Chrysler would I get a response?"

Create a SAB Readerblog


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Blog Advice and Support
Installs and Upgrades
Theme Modifications
Custom Plugins
Theme Design
Conversions and Relocations
Hacked Site Recovery
Mobile Apps Development