If Only He’d Pulled The Trigger

It is a classic ethical dilemma: if you could go back in time and strangle
the baby Hitler, would you?

Well, Henry Tandey, recepient of the Victoria Cross and Britain’s most-highly
decorated private during World War I, was in an even better position to snuff
out the Third Reich before its inception. He had Adolph Hitler in his sights
at Marcoing, France (or perhaps earlier at Ypres).

He didn’t pull the trigger.

Matania’s painting of Tandey at Ypres.

As Wikipedia
puts it: ‘Hitler subsequently saw a newspaper report about Tandey being awarded
the VC, recognized his photo, and kept it. Tandey, now a war hero, was featured
in a famous painting by Italian artist Fortunino Matania, carrying a wounded
soldier at Ypres. In 1937 Hitler asked Tandey’s old regiment for a large photograph
of the painting, which was sent. Captain Weidmann, Hitler’s Adjutant, wrote
the following response: ‘I beg to acknowledge your friendly gift which has
been sent to Berlin through the good offices of Dr. Schwend. The Fuhrer is
naturally very interested in things connected with his own war experiences,
and he was obviously moved when I showed him the picture and explained the
thought which you had in causing it to be sent to him. He has directed me
to send you his best thanks for your friendly gift which is so rich in memories.’
Hitler also obtained a copy of Tandey’s service record.

In 1938 when Neville Chamberlain visited Hitler at his alpine
retreat, the Berghof, for discussions that led to the Munich Agreement, he saw
the picture and asked about it. Hitler said "that man came so near to killing
me that I thought I should never see Germany again, providence saved me from
such devilishly accurate fire as those English boys were aiming at us".
He also asked Chamberlain to convey his best wishes and gratitude to Tandey,
so Chamberlain promised to phone Tandey in person on his return, which he did.

At the outbreak of the Second World War Tandey tried to rejoin
his regiment to make sure "he didn’t escape a second time" but failed
the physical because of old war wounds. He was living in Coventry when the Luftwaffe
bombed it in 1940, and only survived a collapsing building by sheltering in
a doorway. He was also in London during the Blitz and told a journalist in 1940,
"if only I had known what he would turn out to be. When I saw all the people,
woman and children he had killed and wounded I was sorry to God I let him go".’

There is a lesson in here somewhere, but I am not sure what it
is. That an act of kindness can end up loosing a horror upon the world? That
you should always go ahead and shoot? How about this: the world is thoroughly
inscrutable, and second-guessing contingencies is a complete waste of time.

Crossposted from WILLisms.com