Due To High Taxes, Sixty Percent Of New York Cigarettes Are Bootlegged

cigarettes tobacco

Wow:

A new study released by the Tax Foundation shows that over 60 percent of cigarettes are smuggled in to New York to avoid the state’s high cigarette taxes.

The smuggled cigarettes are usually transported from states with lower taxes on cigarettes.

New York State has some of the highest cigarette taxes in the nation with a tax rate in new York City currently at $5.85 cents per pack. The state rate is $4.35 per pack.

There are a number of policy lessons to learn from this example.

First, prohibition doesn’t work. There are a lot of people who have a lot of confidence in the government’s ability to manipulate behavior through taxes, regulations, mandates and bans. But markets are dynamic, and laws are static. Where there is demand, there will be supply. We should have learned this lesson after alcohol prohibition, but we haven’t.

Second, the government’s ability to tax is finite. Once you raise taxes beyond a certain point, people start to act to avoid them by exploiting loopholes, both legal and illegal, and/or moving away from them.

This is why, historically speaking, the federal government has only ever been able to collect about 16 – 18% of GDP in tax revenues no matter how many taxes they levy, and how how tax rates go.

U.S._Federal_Tax_Receipts_as_a_Percentage_of_GDP_1945–2015

Again, once you raise taxes to a certain level, people start to avoid those taxes.

Rob Port is the editor of SayAnythingBlog.com. In 2011 he was a finalist for the Watch Dog of the Year from the Sam Adams Alliance and winner of the Americans For Prosperity Award for Online Excellence. In 2013 the Washington Post named SAB one of the nation's top state-based political blogs, and named Rob one of the state's best political reporters. He writes a weekly column for several North Dakota newspapers, and also serves as a policy fellow for the North Dakota Policy Council.

Related posts

  • Onslaught1066

    The rest are Keistered.

  • WOOF

    Job creation.

    • Spartacus

      As if you really had the aspiration to have one; prerequisites…

      • WOOF

        Can you drive a large truck ? 50,000 cartons in an 18 wheeler, $30 a carton in Virginia $100 a carton in NYC. You get $2.00/carton, meals+ gas+ bail and attorneys fees.

  • matthew_bosch

    What’s the over-under on how many times we go down the path of prohibition and realize we made a huge mistake?

    Is there any hope that someday we repeal laws/regs as the solution?

  • Spartacus

    Due to higher taxes more employees take advantage of pretax deductions to compensate, i.e. more money in their pockets and less in the looters. The smart money isn’t on the beggars and losers.

  • WOOF

    Cigarette taxes work.
    Less kids smoke where the price is high.

    • http://flamemeister.com flamemeister

      So thoughtful, so pious … do you petit-point your own merit badges?

  • mickey_moussaoui

    Too bad Obama has done such a good job killing the economy because if we had a healthy GDP the tax he could be collecting on tobacco sales would be much much higher. Then 18% would look good.

  • headward

    the black market created by government is the invisible hand back-handing NYC

  • Onslaught1066

    Look for the bullet riddled bodies littering the floor of a warehouse on November 15.

    • Guest

      Good to hear your planning on killing yourself November 15, Onshat1066! It’s one of the only actions you’ll take that will make the world a better place.

      • Onslaught1066

        The dumb is strong with this one.

        Perhaps it is too young or illiterate.

        or liberal

Top