Does Owning A Firearm Make You A Bad Parent?

Apparently, for some, it does:

At a recent pediatrician’s visit, the nurse asked me — as part of a series of standard questions — if we had any guns in our house. Like I always do, I answered with a quick, emphatic “no.” I’m not sure why I lie, because we do, in fact, have a gun. My husband keeps one safely stored in a closet. It’s unloaded and completely inaccessible to our daughters. Yet even though we are responsible gun owners, I guess admitting the truth makes me feel like a bad mother.
I understand the implication behind the question: owning a gun may pose a danger to my child’s health and safety. The American Academy of Pediatrics concludes that although one may feel safer by owning a gun, it’s actually safer to maintain a gun-free home. In their official policy statement regarding firearms, the AAP points to some pretty compelling research against gun ownership. They state, “Guns kept in the home are forty-three times more likely to be used to kill someone known to the family than to be used to kill in self-defense.” I understand this, but nevertheless I’ll still keep a firearm.

It still shocks me that doctors ask whether or not you own a gun (this is something I’ve posted on previously). Frankly, if a doctor asked me such a question, they’d get a “None of your damn business” as a response.
As for guns making homes more dangerous, I think that depends on the gun owner. Some people are more respectful of their firearms than others. Some gun-owning families go through generations without a single gun mishap. The vast majority of gun-owning families never see any injuries or deaths from their firearms.
And let’s look at this another way: Owning and using an automobile on a regular base increases the danger of death or injury to your family, yet this is a risk most parents take every day because of the convenience automobiles provide. And again, the danger is relative to the respect the families show their automobiles. Unsafe drivers are in more danger than safe drivers.
Gun owners see the benefits of owning guns as generally outweighing the risks. Yes, guns make homes relatively less safe than homes without guns, but better an armed society as our founders an intended than an unarmed one.

Tags: , ,


«
»
  • http://Array Claude

    I think you’re a bad parent if you own just one gun. You need at least a couple of pistols (one for you and the wife), a shotgun and at least one high powered rifle.

    Remember that it takes the police about 8 minutes to show up.

  • RebTex

    To NOT educate & train your children in the safe use & handling of firearms makes you a bad parent in my opinion.

  • http://accesstheoutdoors.com/ Doug Leier

    i’d guess more people die in hospitals every year than anywhere else…..not having multiple guns in several locations for access by an adult is a tactical error.

  • http://norseberserker.blogspot.com/ Rugby Reader

    I answered the initial question. The answer is “no”.

  • http://proof-proofpositive.blogspot.com/ proof_positive

    Remember that it takes the police about 8 minutes to show up.

    Longer if you’re a “rural American”. Hmm. Maybe that’s why more of them own firearms?

  • 2Hotel9

    “Does Owning A Firearm Make You A Bad Parent?”

    Only if you don’t teach your children how to use it.

  • welder4

    Rugby , I believe the article “is Bush a turd” is in another section, you may want to search for it in the 1500 posts that are here but this is not the one.

  • http://www.myspace.com/johnlocke220 John Locke

    agreed…

  • AR-15

    “Guns make homes relatively less safe than homes without guns” Really? I wonder how “relatively safe” a gun free home would be with some crazy crackhead asshole kicking your door in when you weren’t home and your wife and child were. That was a very uneducated comment on your part me boy. Getting the wrong prescription from an MD kills 6-7 times more people than firearms every year. Does that mean getting your kid a prescription makes you a bad parent as well? If Libtards don’t like the 2ndA they should move to a country that doesn’t guarantee that right.

  • http://www.bikebubba.blogspot.com/ Bike Bubba

    For reference, the AAP’s stand mostly relies on the Kellerman study, which concluded that having a gun in the house makes it far more likely for one to die by gunshot.

    The trouble with the study is that it did not analyze WHOSE gun killed the family member; in most homicide cases, it was clearly someone else’s gun. In other words, what the Kellerman study proved was that gun owners often had a very good reason to own a gun!

    The Kellerman study also did not evaluate the difference between ownership of guns by the law-abiding and those who were not, and did not evaluate at all the possibility (see above again) that guns were more likely to be used to protect human life than to defend it.

    Gun Owners of America has a very good summary of this. If you remove criminals from the sample and evaluate whose gun killed a person, the significance of the Kellerman study disappears.

  • http://proof-proofpositive.blogspot.com/ proof_positive

    Rugrat has trouble following the topic, doesn’t he?
    The BDS is strong with this one!

  • http://norseberserker.blogspot.com/ Rugby Reader

    No. Believing George W. Bush is decent human being does.

  • welder4

    I would say that if you are a liberal and own a gun you are a bad parent because you will not explain to your children that you even have a gun for fear of other liberals finding out that you possess a fire arm. in other words there have been gun control freaks that it is found they own many weapons and fire arms included, it is just they don’t want any one else to own one . so own away with out fear do not listen to the gun control people they own them also . 30 or 40 of them would be maybe sufficient for home protection . boost your safety “buy a fire arm today” store them were they are accessible to you .

  • 11B40

    Greetings:

    I’m more of “the best defense is a good offense” type of guy, so I probably would have just gone with a “Have you ever abused prescription drugs?” response.

  • welder4

    I must go to conservative doctors as they are all the time asking me if I want to go turkey hunting or on a fishing trip in the big lakes. If one were to ask me if I owned a fire arm I would ask them do you own one and if they answer in the affirmative I would then start to compare protection with that of the doctor. I believe that guns are dangerous but they are less dangerous to the one using it then the one that it is being used against, we must have them in this day and time as there are many liberal nuts out there trying to clean up the gene pool and we need protection from them. you will notice that when they get caught owning a fire arm it is never expounded on in the news , we always hear of it in second hand news . mmmm? that might be a good name for a new paper .

  • http://sayanythingblog.com/readers/entry/homosexuality_is_wrong_-_a_compendium move_zig

    At a recent pediatrician’s visit, the nurse asked me — as part of a series of standard questions — if we had any guns in our house.

    Not only are you not a bad parent, the doctor is a bad doctor.

    He has committed what is known as a Boundary Violation.

    Patients do have remedies for the boundary-crossing doctor. In today’s competitive health care market most patients can choose from many doctors. Changing doctors is the simplest solution. A written complaint to the health plan’s membership services department can send a powerful message that boundary violations by doctors will not be tolerated. If the problem persists, patients can file a complaint with the doctor’s state licensing board. Medical licensing boards are increasingly aware of the problem of boundary violations. Although state boards have addressed primarily sexual and financial misconduct, the broad principles they have developed to guide doctors in these areas apply to the entire doctor-patient relationship

    and

    What can you do if your doctor acts inappropriately?

    First, remember that you are not alone. Many gun owners have expressed feelings of anger, frustration and humiliation after their doctors asked inappropriate questions and made ill-informed statements about personal firearms. It is highly unprofessional for doctors to take advantage of their status and your trust to push their personal political agenda. Since you are at a disadvantage in the doctor’s office, don’t feel badly that you were not able to respond as you might have wished.

    If your doctor has violated your boundaries in this manner, DSGL offers two ways in which you can now respond.

    On a related question, jvftz had it exactly right:

    … if circumstances should at any time oblige the government to form an army of any magnitude that army can never be formidable to the liberties of the people while there is a large body of citizens, little, if at all, inferior to them in discipline and the use of arms, who stand ready to defend their own rights and those of their fellow-citizens. This appears to me the only substitute that can be devised for a standing army, and the best possible security against it, if it should exist.

    – Alexander Hamilton, The Federalist No. 29, Concerning the Militia, 01/09/1788

  • welder4

    Owning a gun and knowing how to use it makes you a well protected citizen,

  • http://www.myspace.com/johnlocke220 John Locke

    owning a gun does not make you a bad parent. using it idiotically does. pure and simple…

  • http://proof-proofpositive.blogspot.com/ proof_positive

    Rugrat is exceeding his usual eloquence!

  • Mickey

    Doctors kill many patients from misdiagnosed treatment, somewhere, every day and I continue to put my welfare in their hands equally to my 9mm in my hands.

  • di butler

    I read somewhere that they ask this question while the parent is out of the room, when they are discussing sexual issues with them. I think it was in Ladies Home Journal or Reader’s Digest, because I read it at the doctor’s office.LOL. Seriously, what parent of a young child is going to let them examine/interview your kid with you out of the room? My kids would have looked at them like they were mad had they asked any personal questions of them. Definately wouldn’t have answered. Well, my daughter might have, but she would have said none of your business, hopefully w/o damn in there. Teach your children to not discuss personal family business with strangers. Tell them if they have something private they want to discuss that they don’t want to tell you or the other parent that you will o.k. for them to discuss things with a pastor, or aunt, uncle, etc. Give them a couple of choices and say you can have privacy unless it is something the chosen adult deems harmful. It also will help them as they become teenagers.

    Has this Rugrat person been dropped on their head? Why can’t they make coherent sentences?

  • http://www.bismarckmandanblog.com/ clintf

    Having guns in the house without educating your children about them makes you a bad parent. Just like having a TV in the house and not educating your children that TV wants to influence them without their knowledge makes you a bad parent. Or sending them to school without warning them that teachers are going to have a political agenda in their teaching makes you a bad parent.

    Protecting your children doesn’t just mean telling them to watch for guys in the park wearing trench coats; it means you teach them vigilance against all threats to their safety and the safety of the family.

    Clint
    BismarckMandanBlog.com

  • http://ndgoon.blogspot.com/ goon

    No. Believing George W. Bush is decent human being does.

    What the hell does these two stupid, ridiculous and moronic answers have to do with owning a fire arm? Your post are just as trouble some as that troll Dino. Wow….

    Bush is a piece of turd.

    How about that for what I believe?

  • pparets

    Yeah… like rugrat really knows anything about Bush except what he wants to believe.

  • http://magyartruth.blogspot.com/ Chief RZ

    How about: Do you own any knives, axes, chain saws, cars, crossbows, baseball bats or even rolling pins? A gun is a tool. It is like the fire extinguisher. It can put out a fire (or stop a deranged drugged criminal) before they get out of hand and kill everyone in your house.

  • jvftz

    According to the authors of the Constitution, the purpose of the Second Amendment is and was to make sure that Americans would always have the power to shoot at agents of the Federal Government and state governments, when those governments became abusive or oppressive.

    So–having a gun means you are a GOOD American and a GOOD parent, because it means you can defend your CHILDREN from oppression and abuse by government agents.

  • http://norseberserker.blogspot.com/ Rugby Reader

    Bush is a piece of turd.

    How about that for what I believe?

  • http://www.rabidamerican.net/ Rabid American

    If you love your family remember this…..
    “A gun in your hand is better than 2 cops on the phone!”

    This article indicates how bad it is when others have no respect for your rights and responsibilities!

    It is irresponsible to leave your family unprotected in such a manner. When given proper instruction, all members of the family should understand that firearms are a very effective tool for family emergency protection.

    Children can be taught the necessary lessons and respect for life it takes to keep a firearm in the house.

    My son was taught at a very young age that our firearms were off-limits except for family adults. His lesson for respect of life was achieved at our first hunting trip together at five years old. When he killed a squirrel with my great-granddads’ .22 rifle.

    After celebrating his skilled shot, I made him pick it up and stare it in the eye. I had him notice how warm it still was. I calmly explained to him that he must remember that this animal was NEVER going home again, never going to climb a tree and play again, never going to chatter again, because of his actions. Afterward we discussed at length how this related to using a firearm.

    He is a responsible 25 year old and has a greater respect for life than most other young folks his age……….. he also understand the difference between a “Right” and a “Privilege”……

  • Mickey

    The leading cause of accidental death is “falling”.

  • Rusty

    I don’t have kids, [afraid they'd grow up to be like me!] but I was raised where there were guns in my home, at my Grandparents, Uncles and Aunts, etc.
    I was taught respect for, the safe handling of, and how to shoot these tools at what I am sure would be a young age to many folks.
    The gun grabbers/haters act as though firearms are some sort of living, breathing entity, slithering around the house like a Cobra, Diamondback, or Python [thank you Sam Colt!] ready to strike.
    Education begins at home.
    As a child, had I stuck my fingers in the fan, [remember when they had metal blades?] I doubt whether these same people would have decried the inherent ‘evils’ of fans.
    Yet, common sense seems not to be so common these days.
    [Don't squat with your spurs on, always drink upstream from the herd, never bring a knife to a gunfight, shoot back first, etc.]

    Teddy Kennedy has killed more people with his car than I have with my guns!

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    Having guns in the house without educating your children about them makes you a bad parent.

    Good point.

    I think too often these idiots equate good parenting with removing all threat of harm or failure from your child’s life. As if, upon reaching adulthood, those threats won’t exist no matter who tries to protect them.

    Good parenting means introducing your child to problems and teaching them to cope and protect themselves. Not isolating them from problems.

  • http://sayanythingblog.com robport

    Not that guns are problems.

Create a SAB Readerblog


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Blog Advice and Support
Installs and Upgrades
Theme Modifications
Custom Plugins
Theme Design
Conversions and Relocations
Hacked Site Recovery
Mobile Apps Development