Home Mobile Archives Reader Blogs Register Login

Tuesday, January 01, 2008

Dependence Day

On the 4th of July America celebrates its independence.  The day we threw off the shackles on monarchism and became independent not just as a country, but as a nation of individually and independently free citizens.  Now British Prime Minister Gordon Brown would like to have a corresponding holiday that celebrates what that country is about.

The choice of a far-left British think tank?  July 5th, which is the day Britain passed its national health care system.  Meaning that the British counterpart to America’s independence day would literally be a dependence day.

Gordon Brown should mark the 60th anniversary of the NHS this year by turning its birthday on July 5 into an extra annual bank holiday, a leading Labour thinktank will urge today.

The Fabian Society will say the prime minister has long dreamed of establishing a “British day” to celebrate nationhood. The most appropriate date would be on the anniversary of the health service - an institution which appeals equally to people in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland…

In 2006, before Brown became prime minister, he told a Fabian conference: “What is the British equivalent of the US fourth of July, or even the French 14th of July? ... What is our equivalent for a national celebration of who we are and what we stand for?” He said he had in mind giving the country a new public holiday.

As Mark Steyn notes: “Gotcha. The essence of contemporary British national identity is defined by waiting two years for a hip replacement.”

Apparently, some people think that’s something to be proud of.  And some Americans think it’s something we should want for our country.

Comments

Avatar for Graham

As I’m British, I felt obliged to comment on this, if only to point out some misinformation that is being used here to make a political point.

First, I should admit that I think the Fabian Society’s idea of a holiday for the founding of the NHS is actually pretty dumb. Nevertheless, this Society is not a “far left think tank”, at least not by British standards. Tony Blair was a member, and he’s not exactly renowned for being rabidly left wing. It is currently heavily involved in policymaking for an avowedly centrist government. Admittedly, all politicians outside of the British far right would be considered “far left” by the standards of this blog, but I’m sure you are all aware that the politics in the United States has a centre of gravity well to the right of the rest of the developed world. My point is, disparaging health service supporters as “far left” is totally unjustified in this case, especially given that the concept of a National Health Service enjoys almost unanimous support in Britain, a country more generally known for its innate conservatism than its liberal instincts.

I also feel obliged to stand up for the implied slur on my nation’s institutions, especially given the consistently excellent service I and many others I know have received from the National Health Service over the years. I’m aware that deeply ingrained ideological beliefs would prevent most people here from supporting any kind of government-sponsored health care programme. But, having lived with the NHS since the 1940s, it must be relevant that the British people like having it around, and are prepared to pay taxes in order to sustain it. Abolishing it would be unthinkable - the public outcry would be deafening. It has its flaws, of course, and has not been well managed by recent governments, but then I’m sure any reader would admit that the current American system is not 100% perfect either.

Anyway, to conclude, I’d just like to ask you not to unjustly disparage my country in order to make your own political points. Thanks.

Graham on January 2, 2008 at 03:26 pm
Page 1 of 1        

Post a Comment


Before commenting, please recite:

Grant me the serenity to ignore the trolls,
the courage to debate with honest opponents,
and the wisdom to know the difference.

Name   
Email   
URL   
Human?
  
 

Upload Image    

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Note: Notifications will only be sent to confirmed email addresses.