Home Mobile Archives Reader Blogs Register Login

Monday, July 31, 2006

Cheap Demagogery Can’t Explain Expensive Gas

Thomas Sowell:

Amid all the hysteria among politicians and in the media over rising gasoline prices, and all the outraged indignation about oil company profits and their executives' high pay and lavish perks, has anybody bothered to even estimate how much effect any of this actually has on the price we pay at the pump?

If the profit per gallon of gas were reduced to zero, would that be enough to reduce the price by even a dime? If the oil company executives were to work free of charge, would that be enough to reduce the price of gasoline by even a penny a gallon?

Surely media loudmouths making millions of dollars a year and the multibillion dollar TV networks they work for can afford to get some statistics and buy a pocket calculator to do the arithmetic before spouting off nationwide.

But this is the age of emotion, not analysis.

Politicians are even more hypocritical. The government collects far more in taxes on every gallon of gasoline than the oil companies collect in profits. If oil company profits are "obscene," as some politicians claim, are the government's taxes PG-13?

The very politicians who have piled tax after tax on gasoline over the years, and voted to prohibit oil drilling offshore or in Alaska, and who have made it impossible to build a single oil refinery in decades, are all over the television screens denouncing the oil companies. In other words, those who supply oil are being denounced and demonized by those who have been blocking the supply of oil.

Given the vast amounts of gasoline sold across the length and breadth of this nation, and given the mega-billion dollars involved, whether or not some corporate executive has an inflated pay scale is unlikely to explain the price of gasoline.

It may allow some people in the media to vent their emotions and some politicians to create a bogeyman, since they can't play St. George without a dragon. But cheap demagoguery cannot explain expensive gas.


Read the whole thing.

Comments

Avatar for Mickey

This certainly is the age of emotion. Just look at the the newest self exaulted ruler of demagoguery, Al Gore. If not for the drama of Global Warming he would be little more than the ghost of politics past.

Unfortunately, American industry has to play into this nonsense because otherwise they risk losing half of their potential customer base due to negative propoganda from the mass politics involved.

Demagoguery is an exercise in unidimensionality. The perfect ruse for a slimeball politician.

Mickey on August 1, 2006 at 04:22 am
Avatar for LoadTheMule

YA’know the thing I just hate about Thomas Sowell?  The same thing I hate about Walter Williams; he makes so much sense.  Damn, it’s hard to be a demagogue around him. *sigh*

/sarcasm

Regards…

LoadTheMule on August 1, 2006 at 04:33 am
Avatar for The Whistler

What we need is a breakdown of where our gas dollar goes.  More specifically for a gallon of domestically produced oil of which 1/2 is roduced on US owned land.

State gas tax
Federal gas tax
oil lease
oil royalties
property tax-refineries etc
other fees
income tax on oil company
income and payroll tax on payrolls

as opposed to
Infrastructure costs
payroll costs (inc benefits)
any other production cost
pipeline costs
gas station infrastruture and costs

Finally we have
Oil company profits
pipeline profits
gas station profits

I’ve looked but haven’t found anything like this.

The Whistler on August 1, 2006 at 04:45 am
Avatar for Mickey

The gas station makes more profit on that two-day-old hot dog under the heat lamp than they do on a gallon of gasoline.

I pay $.51 cent per gallon in gas tax per gallon. Exxon, for example gets $.31 cent in profit per gallon of gas. Which is pretty good considering that Hurst built his empire a quarter at a time.

Demagoguery is definately hard on the pocket book.

Mickey on August 1, 2006 at 05:32 am
Avatar for Steve L.

If Big Oil® is making so much money, how come we only hear about the profits of Exxon/Mobil?  Why aren’t we hearing about obscene profits from all the other Big Oil® companies?  We all know the answer to that question.

Big Oil® is not price gouging.  That is the only explanation.  Exxon/Mobil is making larger profits because...get ready...they are bigger and can do things more cheaply thus their cost of producing a gallon of gasoline is lower than that of their competitors.

Some would ask why then doesn’t Exxon/Mobil lower their prices since their costs or lower.  Why should they?  If their competitors mst charge $2.80 a gallon to break even, why would we expect Exxon/Mobil to charge $2.70 a gallon?  I know I sure wouldn’t do it.  I might go $2.77 or $2.78, but not any lower.  All a lower price would do is sacrifice profits unnecessarily.  Ultimately, isn’t that why a company exists?  To make as much profit as possible?

Exxon/Mobil is not the one setting the price, it’s their competitors.  Griping about Exxon/Mobil isn’t going to change that.

Steve L. on August 1, 2006 at 06:00 am
Page 1 of 1        

Post a Comment


Before commenting, please recite:

Grant me the serenity to ignore the trolls,
the courage to debate with honest opponents,
and the wisdom to know the difference.

Name   
Email   
URL   
Human?
  
 

Upload Image    

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Note: Notifications will only be sent to confirmed email addresses.