Byron Dorgan Apparently Wrote Another Book, This One Blaming Recession On Deregulation

Byron Dorgan, whose previous book Take This Job and Ship It was a study in economic illiteracy, may have actually outdone that effort with his latest book Reckless!: How Debt, Deregulation, and Dark Money Nearly Bankrupted America (And How We Can Fix It!).
Dorgan was on CNN recently for a softball interview that he may as well have paid for as an informercial for his book (you gotta love it when the supposedly objective interviewer asks Dorgan if he’d like a minute to say “I told you so”) blaming all the ills of the economy on deregulation, and pretending like it was the same sort of deregulation that lead to the bank failures of the 1930′s.


I’d say that I’m surprised that Dorgan gets away with touting this sort of malarkey, but I’m not really. After years of distorting and meddling in the markets, the big government liberals responsible for the meddling need a scapegoat and the cause of limited government (bolstered by a presumption of historical ignorance about the Great Depression era specifically) fits the bill perfectly.
Of course, the Great Depression and the banking failures of the 1930′s weren’t caused by deregulation. Herbert Hoover, in fact, was a progressive and an opponent to laissez faire principles. The Great Depression was caused by a recession brought on some very poor agricultural years (America was still very much an agrarian country back then) exacerbated by government meddling such as tax hikes on the rich, protectionism, expansive (and expensive!) public works projects.
And the modern economic recession was caused by the government making credit far too easy to obtain for people who had no business obtaining, something they did based on the false notion that more homeownership and more spending in the economy (even if it ran up debt the people owning the homes and doing the spending had no chance of paying off) would make our economy stronger.
It didn’t.
Deregulation is not a bad thing. But people like Dorgan, who are perennial proponents of bigger and bigger government, find it to be a handy scapegoat. It fits their ideological assumptions perfectly, and completely exonerates themselves from any blame.

Tags: , , ,


«
»
  • http://Array robert108

    108 makes a good argument for more regulation.

    Actually, little buzzy, it’s an argument for keeping govt out of the market. No sane broker would ever offer 90% margin, just like no sane lender would lower qualifications for home loans, unless there is pressure from the govt to make things “affordable” by violating good business standards.
    Didn’t expect you to understand that, little buzzy.
    Economic crisis is always caused by wasteful social spending and social engineering schemes that rig markets to get a predetermined social outcome.
    Computers get faster and cheaper due to free market forces, not govt regulations, little buzzy.
    There’s no “bubble” in the computer industry, and there is plenty of profit.
    The free market is better for everybody.

  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    The Great Depression was caused by a recession brought on some very poor agricultural years (America was still very much an agrarian country back then) exacerbated by government meddling such as tax hikes on the rich, protectionism, expansive (and expensive!) public works projects.

    Milton Friedman said that the depression became a recession due to an inappropriate response by the Federal Reserve. Specifically they shrunk the money supply by a third.

  • Dino2

    When you people talk about government “liberals” meddling in the sacred “free” markets, it’s like you’re talking about a parallel universe. There have been no liberals with any policy-making power since the early 60s.

    We’ve been dominated completely by conservatism for at least 30 years.
    But you keep trying to convince people that, despite winning most of the elections and holding the reins for nearly the entire last 3 decades, these mysterious, invisible, mythical liberals were really the ones in control.

  • brain trust

    Saturday’s Section C of the Fargo Forum proves that he has no clue of what is happening in Washington, or his is out to deflect any blame away from our dictator. At the end of the article on page 1 apparently his staff released a message that he wrote a letter to the CEOs of Chrysler and GM to question the wisdom of shutting down dealerships in rural America. (Forum Story)

    The 5th paragraph on page C2 says that shedding dealerships is part of the restructuring demands from Obama’s administration. (AP Story)

  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    Bill Clinton used the Carter Era Community reinvestment act to pressure banks into loaning money to individuals who weren’t able to pay for the money. The depression era Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, being run by Clintonites facilitated more and more loans for houses that there was no true market for.

    Democrats in the decade blocked needed reforms of Fannie and Freddie.

  • AR-15

    Good Lord, are we ever gonna vote out old “helmet head”?

  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    Dorgan’s a joke. He writes a book lamenting loss of jobs which was certainly made much worse by his support of extreme enviromentalism, overly reach labor laws, his high business taxes and other regulations.

    Now he is upset over the latest recession which was triggered by the job losses as above AND his support of crappy mortgage regulations.

  • Wing Chun Geologist

    We’ve been dominated completely by conservatism for at least 30 years.

    But you keep trying to convince people that, despite winning most of the elections and holding the reins for nearly the entire last 3 decades, these mysterious, invisible, mythical liberals were really the ones in control.

    Yes we’ve won elections. But Republican politicians have been complete pussies when it comes to using their offices to make any meaningful changes.

    That’s why we’ve had to act like miniscule tax cuts were a victory when we should have abolished the IRS and income tax completely.

    That’s why we still have a welfare system that subsidizes an illigitamacy rate somewhere between 30 and 40 percent.

    That’s why we’ve had our financial system wrecked by policies meant to extend home ownership to people who couldn’t afford to buy homes.

    That’s why CAFE regulations (along with lousy union contracts) have decimated the domestic auto industry.

    That’s why the budget keeps growing and growing, even when there are Republican in office.

    …because once they get elected, most Republicans turn into pussies who won’t fight for lower taxes, smalled government, and individual rights & responsibilities.

  • http://www.valleydeals.com/cgi-bin/board2/YaBB.pl Kevin

    Tony Bender cranked out another one for Byron, eh?

  • http://SayAnythingBlog.com The_Whistler_ofnd

    Bill Clinton used the Carter Era Community reinvestment act to pressure banks into loaning money to individuals who weren’t able to pay for the money. The depression era Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, being run by Clintonites facilitated more and more loans for houses that there was no true market for.

    Democrats in the decade blocked needed reforms of Fannie and Freddie.

  • robert108

    TW: The Crash of ’29 was fueled by a very similar social engineering tactic as the one which produced the home loan crash: in order to make stocks “affordable” to all Americans, brokers were permitted to sell stock at 90% margin, which meant that a person could buy a stock at only 10% of its face value. That was OK when stocks were going up, but when a stock went down by 10% or more, the owner got a “margin call” from his or her broker, demanding more money to cover the shortfall. This led to widespread panic, bank runs and bankruptcies, just like the effort to create “affordable housing” caused last year’s crash, with a little help from Chuck Shumer to set it off with a run on one big bank. In ’29, a small dip in the market triggered a landslide. The 90% margin had created a huge bubble, since a false demand signal was generated, just like the lowered loan requirements for “affordable housing” created a false demand signal in the mid-Nineties.
    Bad monetary policy only made things worse, but was not the fundamental cause.

  • Slacker Deluxe

    I remember this ass hat back in the day, always whining that Greenspan was keeping interest rates too high. We now know that the cheap money had something to do with the mess we are now in.

  • http://verizonwireless.com/ ND in MD

    At least Byron got one thing right when he said….his prediction in 1999 and on TARP does mean he is clairvoyant or smart…

    Yes, Byron, we understand stand you are not smart.

  • Buzz

    108 makes a good argument for more regulation. Good job. Dorgan was right.

  • jimmypop

    the modern economic recession was caused by the government making credit far too easy to obtain for people who had no business obtain

    looks like you should write a book… i just wish i would have taped all the discussions my friends and i had before any of this happened…. it seems we are smarter than many people. actually, id like to think most people saw this coming before all the talking heads did.

  • ec99

    “Tony Bender cranked out another one for Byron, eh?”

    I cannot figure out why anyone would think that Dorgan could author a book. In the past 50 years there been perhaps a handful of politicians with enough intelligence and language skills to be so creative. Moynahan comes to mind. Certainly not JFK, Clinton, Carter, nor Dorgan.

Create a SAB Readerblog


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus

Blog Advice and Support
Installs and Upgrades
Theme Modifications
Custom Plugins
Theme Design
Conversions and Relocations
Hacked Site Recovery
Mobile Apps Development