Home Mobile Archives Reader Blogs Register Login

Sunday, March 12, 2006

Baseball? Yeah. Classic? No.

For an event that is entirely a made-for-TV and a made-to-sell-caps-and-jerseys affair, the World Baseball Classic has been in the news quite a bit this week.

It started with Wednesday's loss by Team USA to Canada. That landed it on the back pages of the New York tabloids and had people discussing it on sports-talk stations like NYC's WFAN all day. The US, after 1 game, was in peril of not making it out of Round 1 of pool play. Yesterday, any fears of that happening were allayed when the US beat South Africa (Baseball in South Africa? Who knew?) 17 - 0. It's not often that you see a baseball team put up two TDs and a field goal, but it happens. Just add South Africa, and you're there.

The bigger and more interesting story to folks of a wonkish bent was what happened Thursday in Puerto Rico as Cuba faced off against the Netherlands. In the stands behind home plate, Jose Garcia, a Cuban exile living in Puerto Rico, created an international incident when he flashed a homemade sign reading "ABAJO FIDEL" (loose translation: Down with Fidel). The reason this was such a big deal is that the game was being carried live on Cuban national television. Egg was all over Castro's face.

Fidel isn't big on this kind of thing, and usually reacts by throwing people in jail or organizing meaningless compulsory protests in Havana. In this case, in addition to calling for the predictable street protest, Cuba demanded action from Major League Baseball, hinting that they'd pull out of the tournament if MLB didn't put an end to the anti-Castro messages:

Some members of the Cuban team left their dugout to watch the incident before continuing with the game. But afterward, Cuba refused to participate in the mandatory postgame news conference and, according to a high-ranking San Juan police official, threatened to pull out of the event.

''What happened was a great provocation on the part of four or five counter revolutionaries using signs and offensive language that violated the established norms of the organizing committee,'' said a statement released by the Cuban team. ``The local police, instead of fixing the problem, showed their support for [the protesters].''

The statement went on to say the Cuban delegation would meet with Major League Baseball officials early today to determine ''a solution'' before tonight's scheduled game with Puerto Rico.


MLB capitulated and pulled a Google as they did their part to help crush the dissent. Prior to the start of Friday's matchup between Puerto Rico and Cuba, "local organizers" banned the display of signs that are political in nature. To anyone who isn't drinking the Kool-Aid being served by the league that this is some sort of world-class, important international competition, this is completely unsurprising.

After all, if Cuba bailed from the tournament, those Cuba caps and jerseys would not exactly be popular items at the souvineur stands, and the whole point of this tournament is to make money for Major League Baseball. Lord knows it isn't about the highest level of competition. If that was the case, it wouldn't be held during Spring Training. Some of the best players aren't even in the tournament, for crying out loud.

Friday night, before a sign-free audience, Team Cuba took the field against Puerto Rico. An official government communication sent out earlier had urged the players to "respond to the provocations with hits, home runs, strikes, outs."

They lost to Puerto Rico 12-2. Sounds like they got the "outs" part right, at least.

Cuba's next game is Sunday, when they open Round 2 in an all-Communist matchup against Venezuela. In a tournament that, ridiculously, allows ties in baseball games, I wonder if we can get another exception made to the rules.

That's one game where I'd be happy to see both nations lose.

Alex Nunez blogs at The Noonz Wire.

Comments

Avatar for richard

Uh Venezuala’s commie president was elected by popular vote, just wanted to point that out. 

richard on March 12, 2006 at 08:13 am
Rob
Rob
17374 comments
Send a private message

That doesn’t make him any less of a power-grabbing Commie.


Image and video hosting by TinyPic

Rob’s recently listened-to songs:

robport.gif border=0

Rob on March 12, 2006 at 08:27 am
Avatar for richard

Never said it did rob.

richard on March 12, 2006 at 08:34 am

Richard, Chavez’s path to power was not the point here. Plus, like Rob said, he’s still a Commie scumbunny.

Like Fidel. 

Alex Nunez on March 12, 2006 at 10:15 am

For an event that is entirely a made-for-TV and a made-to-sell-caps-and-jerseys affair, the World Baseball Classic has been in the news quite a bit this week.

I don’t think it’s quite like that. They have an opportunity to draw more attention to their sport, which could increase the quality of play. Was the 1992 men’s basketball "Dream Team" a "made-for-TV and a made-to-sell-caps-and-jerseys affair?" I certainly don’t think so, and these are substantially the same thing.

Dave on March 12, 2006 at 12:08 pm

Dave, the ‘92 Dream team was different because at least it was the Olympics. Say what you want, but the Olympics are very much the Real Deal.

Also, Dave, if you don’t think the NBA and USA basketball made an absolute mint selling Dream Team stuff, you’re crazy. I worked in a store that only sold licensed team apparel at the time. We sold out of that stuff as quickly as it came in. I personally have a Ewing jersey hanging in my garage. The  Jordan jerseys? They vanished almost instantaneously.

(As an aside, I dont like the NBA guys playing in the O’s anymore. I have less of a problem with the NHL players participating, because I get the distinct impression that a majority of them really care. The NBA teams the last two cycles have shown a lot of apathy.) 

The WBC is an invented tournament that takes place at a ridiculous time. The idea that this was done to promote the interests of baseball is pure fantasy (unless, of course, you’re talking about the Major League’s financial interests).

 I know you’re a big baseball guy, and if you like it, that’s great.  But at least admit that this is little more than a gaudy costume party where some of the best invitees are no-shows.

In the meantime, I find myself checking ESPN’s shill-o-rama coverage to make sure that Jeter, A-Rod, Damon and Bernie haven’t gone and unnecessarily injured themselves in pursuit of the Bud Selig Trophy. 

Alex Nunez on March 12, 2006 at 12:31 pm
Avatar for FreeRepublicans.com

Uh Venezuala’s commie president was elected by popular vote, just wanted to point that out. 

So was Hitler, elected that is.

FreeRepublicans.com on March 12, 2006 at 12:47 pm

Dave, the ‘92 Dream team was different because at least it was the Olympics. Say what you want, but the Olympics are very much the Real Deal.

And why is it that the Olympics are such a big deal? Because they’ve been around for 100 years.

There’s a chance history may prove me wrong, but I think there’s a very nice parallel between the first Olympics and the first World Baseball Classic. (That is, a lot of top athletes skipped the first Olympics, because they didn’t think it would be an important event… things like that.)

The WBC is an invented tournament that takes place at a ridiculous time.

Again, I don’t see how the WBC is any more "invented" than the Olympics. Further, spring is the only reasonable time it could be held. They couldn’t just take three weeks off in the middle of the season--the postseason lasts until the end of October as it is.

But at least admit that this is little more than a gaudy costume party where some of the best invitees are no-shows.

I read a story on ESPN a few days ago on how most businesses in the Dominican Republic (or Venezuela) were letting their workers off early so they could watch their team in the WBC--they made it seem like this is a national holiday for them.

I’d also point out that the MLB participation for the WBC was far better than the NBA’s participation in the ‘04 Olympics, which several talented players skipped (10 of the first 12 they contacted dropped out; the only real superstars were Tim Duncan and Allen Iverson).

Dave on March 12, 2006 at 12:58 pm

So was Hitler, elected that is.

Heh. Remember, according to Rob, Hitler’s rise to power was an act of democracy and can’t be construed as a loss of individual freedom. He writes:

 If we did do something stupid like outlaw gun ownership or vote down free speech it would be a terribe, terrible thing.  Yet it would still be an act of democracy, and as long as the processes remain in place to undo what we have done to ourselves in the future I don’t see it as a violation of individual freedom.

http://sayanythingblog.com/2006/03/0 3/an_end_to_presidential_term_limits/#c61604

Dave on March 12, 2006 at 01:07 pm

A pro-WBC article on ESPN.com? Gee, what a shocker.

 I am going to agree to disagree with you on this one, Dave. I just think the WBC is idiotic. Maybe in 10 years I’ll be proven wrong. We’ll see.

Baseball: Good.

World Baseball Classic: Not. 

I’ll wait for the real classic in October. That’s the one that counts. 

Alex Nunez on March 12, 2006 at 01:10 pm
Avatar for brenarlo

While people across the world view this as a more nationalistic deal, people in the US just want their (MLB) team to win.  I love the Oakland Athletics.  I don’t want any of my beloved Oakland A’s playing alongside someone playing for the Angels.  And I certainly don’t want to have to cheer for Angels… I don’t care what National team they play for.  People in the Dominican Republic love their Dominican team, while Americans love their individual team.  People in the DOminican Republic watch, love, and follow all of their players in the MLB, while Americans don’t follow their favorite American ballplayers....  they generally follow their team.   

brenarlo on March 12, 2006 at 02:05 pm
Avatar for calm down, USA

Oops!! Alex, it looks like it was possible for the US to crash out after all, despite beating South Africa. Perhaps you’ll stop calling your domestic championship the "World Series" now… heh heh.

Now I know there is a myth that "World" was originally a sponsor name, but it wasn’t. And I saw a report on the Yankees recently, which said: "23 world titles - no team, in any sport, has more." Utterly ridiculous.

I do however wish you luck in the World Cup; you’ve got some great footballers and an exciting style of play.

calm down, USA on March 17, 2006 at 02:40 am
Page 1 of 1        

Post a Comment


Before commenting, please recite:

Grant me the serenity to ignore the trolls,
the courage to debate with honest opponents,
and the wisdom to know the difference.

Name   
Email   
URL   
Human?
  
 

Upload Image    

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Note: Notifications will only be sent to confirmed email addresses.