Home Mobile Archives Reader Blogs Register Login

Monday, April 10, 2006

Are International Politics Moving Right?

It is looking like Silvio Berlusconi will remain in power in Italy, though election results are still too close to call. If Berlusconi wins, however, it will be an interesting extension of a trend I've been talking about for a few months now here on Say Anything.

Berlusconi has been a supporter of the war in Iraq. Italian troops are gone now, and he has had to soften his position on Iraq in the past, but he is and was a supporter none-the-less. If he remains in office it will be further evidence of a right-ward shift in international politics.

Here is a list, culled from my memory, of international leaders who have been elected (or re-elected as the case may be) within the last year or so:

  • George W. Bush, the mastermind behind the invasion of Iraq.


  • John Howard, Prime Minister of Australia and staunch supporter of the war in Iraq.


  • Stephen Harper, Prime Minister of Canada and member of that country's conservative party. Not sure of his view on the war in Iraq, but his election certainly marks a shift to the right from his predecessor's (Paul Martin) uber-liberal government and he is already in the process of warming what had become cool relations with America under Martin.


  • Andrea Merkel, Chancellor of Germany. While she is no "right winger" she is certainly to the right of her predecessor Gerhard Schroeder, not to mention more friendly to America.


  • Tony Blair, Prime Minister of Great Britain. Blair is no conservative in his politics, but his administration (at least from an American perspective) is marked by its close ties to America and the Bush administration, especially over the war in Iraq.


The election of every politician mentioned above marks a notable shift to the right in the leadership of the countries they represent. Add Berlusconi to the list and you can see my point. Obviously America's left/right nomenclature doesn't directly apply to the unique political landscape of each of the above named countries, but the I do believe that this trend is noteworthy.

Liberals here in America have told us over and over again that President Bush is making America "less popular" in the world. We are told that our foreign policies are making our country a "loaner" in the international community. Yet, since President Bush was elected it would seem as though those who make up the international political community have moved markedly to the right in their politics. Rather than voting in favor of distancing themselves from America and its policies it appears as though foreign citizens are consistently electing leaders who will move their respective countries closer to America.

Which, of course, totally flies in the face of everything we are told by the media/political left tells us about our country and its standing in the world.

Comments

Avatar for Bat One

I think it would also be interesting to know who was responsible for the exit polling that has said all afternoon that Berlusconi had lost.  It couldn’t be the same folks who called Florida for AlGore in 2000, or Ohio for Kerry in 2004, could it?  I smell a Zogby-esque rat.

Bat One on April 10, 2006 at 01:30 pm
Avatar for Zsa Zsa

Will Franklin of WILLisms.com worked for the Bush Gore campaign. That was the biggest fiasco. He gave me the laptop he got for working for the Bush campaign. Yay! Isn’t that nice of Will?

Zsa Zsa on April 10, 2006 at 01:45 pm
Avatar for Bat One

Doc,

True enough, Sir.  But what is most distressing is that for the most part, those on the Left don’t know the difference and don’t care either.

I am absolutely convinced that the most significant difference between those on/in the Right and those on the Left comes down to values and motivation.  On the Right we subscribe to principle, while on the Left partisan expediency is the driving force.  Nothing else matters. 

Bat One on April 10, 2006 at 01:48 pm
Avatar for Zsa Zsa

Bat One...That is very observant and most assuredly accurate.

Zsa Zsa on April 10, 2006 at 01:54 pm
Avatar for Anon

While overall there appears to be a shift towards the right and America the reasons behind each are varied and don’t suggest a rightward shift.

Individually…

John Howard was re-elected because the Oz economy has had large growth for a number of years which Howard claims credit for (It’s is actually because China’s growth has spurred on the Australian economy) and Howard has no effective opposition.

Stephen Harper was elected probably because Canadians were fed up/ bored/ frustrated by about 15 years of the Liberals.

Andrea Merkel was elected(just!) because Schroeder did nothing for a stagnant economy and didn’t look as if he was going to. He was so anti-US/anti-war because he needed the votes and now Merkel is just taking a fairly sensible position that isn’t anti-US or very pro-US it’s more about restoring a relationship with the US.

Blair (my PM) was re-elected because he was still popular enough even though (not because) he went to war and the Conservatives were still a joke.

And Bush -well I still can’t believe it, myself. But I presume he hadn’t lost his core support (Christians, Republicans -that on it’s own was almost enough to get him elected). And the war hadn’t gone that wrong at that point to lose him his core support and he was still scaring everyone into voting for him. 

Anon on April 10, 2006 at 02:10 pm
Avatar for TwoHotel9

Anon, you are so right. People in America were scared in 2004, scared that Kerry might possibly be elected to the Presidency. Vote fraud by Dems is well documented, not to mention their repeated attempts to throw out the absentee ballots cast by US military personnel overseas.

TwoHotel9 on April 10, 2006 at 03:34 pm
Avatar for MikeAdamson

Bat One opines

On the Right we subscribe to principle, while on the Left partisan expediency is the driving force.  Nothing else matters.

My experience has been that principle and partisanship belong exclusively to neither right nor left. I personally know very principled conservatives and liberals and very partisan liberals and conservatives which leads me to conclude that they are both characteristics of individual personaly rather than political identification or philosophy.

MikeAdamson on April 10, 2006 at 07:52 pm
Avatar for MikeAdamson

I almost forgot...the Italian vote seem pretty close although the results have the centre-left winning. They’ll be recounting for months I’m sure.

MikeAdamson on April 10, 2006 at 07:56 pm
Avatar for Dave

It is looking like Silvio Berlusconi will be removed from power in Italy, though election results are still too close to call. If Berlusconi loses, however, it will be an interesting extension of a trend I’ve been talking about for a few months now here on Say Anything.

Here is a list, culled from my memory, of international leaders who have been elected (or re-elected as the case may be) within the last year or so:

Finland: Tarja Halonen, a radical left-winger, was re-elected.

Chile elected Michelle Bachelet, a divorced agnostic and socialist.

Spain elected Jose Zapatero, a Socialist and an opponent of the War.

Venezuela’s 5th Republic Movement (Chavez’s Party) received an overwhelming victory.

Evo Morales, of ""The worst enemy of humanity is capitalism" fame, is elected president of Bolivia.

The election of every politician mentioned above marks a notable shift to the left in the leadership of the countries they represent. Add Prodi to the list and you can see my point. Obviously America’s left/right nomenclature doesn’t directly apply to the unique political landscape of each of the above named countries, but the I do believe that this trend is noteworthy.

Or, perhaps, some countries are going to the left and other countries are going to the right.

Dave on April 10, 2006 at 08:55 pm
Avatar for graeme

peru is having a runoff election with a left winger in the lead as well.

graeme on April 10, 2006 at 10:55 pm
Avatar for Dave

peru is having a runoff election with a left winger in the lead as well.

Ah yes, I missed that one.

Dave on April 11, 2006 at 01:36 pm
Page 1 of 1        

Post a Comment


Before commenting, please recite:

Grant me the serenity to ignore the trolls,
the courage to debate with honest opponents,
and the wisdom to know the difference.

Name   
Email   
URL   
Human?
  
 

Upload Image    

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Note: Notifications will only be sent to confirmed email addresses.

    

By submitting your comment you agree to our terms of service.